Sancaktutar Ahmet Ali, Söylemez Haluk, Bozkurt Yasar, Penbegül Necmettin, Atar Murat
Department of Urology, University of Dicle, Diyarbakır, Turkey.
Urol Res. 2012 Aug;40(4):317-25. doi: 10.1007/s00240-011-0409-3. Epub 2011 Aug 11.
Aim of study was to present costs of forgotten ureteral stents extraction so as to distract attentions of the urologists on this issue. Medical files of 27 accessible patients who referred to our clinics between 2001 and 2010 because of forgotten ureteral stent were retrospectively analyzed. The indwelling time of double-j stents (DJS) was calculated from the time of its insertion. Costs related to radiological investigations, all invasive, and noninvasive interventions, duration of hospital stay, and medical treatments used were calculated. These estimations were based on 2010 prices determined by Turkey Ministry of Health. Mean age of the patients was 31.2 (8-86 years) years. Mean indwelling time of ureteral DJSs was 36.7 months (14-84 months). Seventy-one [extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL), n = 26; invasive/noninvasive interventions, n = 32] procedures were applied for 27 patients. In six patients without incrustation, after a single session of ESWL DJSs could be removed cystoscopically. A various combination of a multimodal therapy was used for other 21 patients. Total financial burden of 27 patients was US $ 34,300. Cost of treatment was estimated to be 6.9-fold (1.8- to 21-fold) higher than an average timely stent extraction. Financial burden of the treatments increased in parallel with the duration of the stent retention (p = 0.001). Management of forgotten DJS is time consuming, difficult, complicated, risky, and costly. Therefore; financial burden, increased labour loss, and impaired quality of life brought by the application of these modalities must not be forgotten.
本研究的目的是呈现遗忘输尿管支架取出的成本,以引起泌尿外科医生对该问题的关注。对2001年至2010年间因遗忘输尿管支架而转诊至我们诊所的27例可获取病历的患者进行回顾性分析。双J支架(DJS)的留置时间从其插入时间开始计算。计算与放射学检查、所有侵入性和非侵入性干预、住院时间以及所用医疗治疗相关的成本。这些估计基于土耳其卫生部确定的2010年价格。患者的平均年龄为31.2岁(8 - 86岁)。输尿管DJS的平均留置时间为36.7个月(14 - 84个月)。对27例患者实施了71项[体外冲击波碎石术(ESWL),n = 26;侵入性/非侵入性干预,n = 32]操作。在6例无结石形成的患者中,单次ESWL治疗后可通过膀胱镜取出DJS。对其他21例患者采用了多模式治疗的各种组合。27例患者的总经济负担为34,300美元。治疗成本估计比平均及时取出支架高6.9倍(1.8至21倍)。治疗的经济负担随着支架留置时间的延长而增加(p = 0.001)。处理遗忘的DJS耗时、困难、复杂、有风险且成本高昂。因此,绝不能忘记这些治疗方式所带来的经济负担、劳动力损失增加以及生活质量受损。