Bolechała Filip, Strona Marcin, Konopka Tomasz
Z Katedry i Zakładu Medycyny Sadowej UJ CM.
Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol. 2010 Oct-Dec;60(4):207-15.
Homicides committed by insane offenders have been rarely investigated from the forensic point of view in a comprehensive and detailed manner. The objective of the study was to describe and characterize the modus operandi and personal characteristics in cases when more than one victim was killed and the perpetrator was deemed insane in judicial proceedings. Differences between single and multiple-vitim homicides in the population of insane murderers were also examined. Complete dossiers and forensic examination reports of 21 homicide victims killed by 9 individuals were retrospectively analyzed. The comparative control group consisted of 41 cases with only one victim killed by a single insane perpetrator. The offence and offender variables were subjected to a comparative statistical analysis. The results indicated some specific factors that can be regarded as distinctive features more commonly observed in multiple vs. single victim killings perpetrated by insane individuals. There was a significant correlation between, psychosis with depressive delusions, emotional/affective motivation, common domicile and a positive relationship between the perpetrator and the victim, infanticide committed in the perpetrator's offspring, actions with elements of planning, attacking victims while asleep, attacking from the back rather than from the front, concentration and clustering of injuries in one region of the body and multiple psychotic homicides. The results and conclusions of this study can provide practical, useful implications for homicide investigations, offender profiling or forensic psychiatric and psychological evidence.
从法医角度对精神错乱罪犯实施的杀人案件进行全面、详细调查的情况很少见。本研究的目的是描述和刻画在司法程序中造成多名受害者死亡且犯罪者被认定为精神错乱的案件中的作案手法和个人特征。同时还研究了精神错乱杀人犯群体中单人作案与多人作案杀人案件之间的差异。对9人杀害21名受害者的完整卷宗和法医检查报告进行了回顾性分析。比较对照组由41起仅有一名受害者被一名精神错乱的犯罪者杀害的案件组成。对犯罪和犯罪者变量进行了比较统计分析。结果表明,在精神错乱者实施的多人作案与单人作案杀人案件中,某些特定因素可被视为更常观察到的显著特征。伴有抑郁性妄想的精神病与情感/情绪动机、共同居住以及犯罪者与受害者之间的积极关系、对犯罪者后代实施的杀婴行为、带有计划要素的行为、趁受害者熟睡时攻击、从背后而非正面攻击、身体某一区域的伤口集中和聚集以及多起精神病杀人案件之间存在显著相关性。本研究的结果和结论可为杀人案件调查、犯罪者侧写或法医精神病学及心理学证据提供切实有用的启示。