Joyce Michael, Worrakitpoonpon Tirawut
Laboratoire de Physique Nucléaire et Hautes Énergies, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris 6, CNRS IN2P3 UMR 7585, 4 Place Jussieu, F-75752 Paris Cedex 05, France.
Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2011 Jul;84(1 Pt 1):011139. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.84.011139. Epub 2011 Jul 25.
We study quasistationary states (QSSs) resulting from violent relaxation in the one-dimensional self-gravitating "sheet model," revisiting in particular the question of the adequacy of the theory of Lynden-Bell (LB) to describe them. For "waterbag" initial conditions characterized by a single phase-space density, the prediction of this theory is, in this model, a function of only one parameter, which can conveniently be chosen to be the ratio of the energy to that in the degenerate limit. Studying a class of such initial conditions in which the shape of the initial waterbag is varied, we find that the LB predictions are reasonably good always in the low-energy region, while at higher energies (i.e., in the nondegenerate limit) they are generally not even qualitatively correct, although certain initial conditions can still be found where they are as good as at low energy. We find notably that, in line with what has been observed by Levin et al. in some other models, when LB theory does not work, the QSSs are always characterized by the presence of a degenerate core, which these authors explain as the result of dynamical resonances. In short, LB theory appears to be a good approximation only when violent relaxation is sufficiently "gentle," and otherwise a degenerate core-halo structure results.
我们研究了一维自引力“薄片模型”中剧烈弛豫产生的准稳态(QSSs),特别重新审视了林登 - 贝尔(LB)理论描述它们的充分性问题。对于以单相空间密度为特征的“水袋”初始条件,在该模型中,此理论的预测仅是一个参数的函数,该参数可方便地选为能量与简并极限下能量的比值。研究一类这样的初始条件,其中初始水袋的形状是变化的,我们发现LB预测在低能量区域总是相当不错的,而在较高能量(即非简并极限)下,它们通常甚至在定性上都不正确,尽管仍能找到某些初始条件,在这些条件下它们与低能量时一样好。我们特别发现,与莱文等人在其他一些模型中所观察到的一致,当LB理论不适用时,QSSs总是以存在简并核心为特征,这些作者将其解释为动力学共振的结果。简而言之,LB理论似乎只有在剧烈弛豫足够“温和”时才是一个好的近似,否则会产生简并核心 - 晕结构。