Creutzig U, Ritter J, Schellong G
Berlin-Frankfurt-Münster Study Group, FRG.
Blood. 1990 May 15;75(10):1932-40.
The main difference between the two cooperative studies on therapy of childhood acute myelogenous leukemia AML-BFM-78 and AML-BFM-83 was the addition of an 8-day ADE (cytosine arabinoside, daunorubicin, etoposide) induction treatment in the second study. Due to this intensification, the relapse rate, but not the rate of induction failures, was reduced. The probability of a 6-year event-free survival increased from 38%, SD 4%, in study AML-BFM-78 to 49%, SD 4%, in study AML-BFM-83, P = .08. The improvement of the 6-year event-free interval (EFI) was significant in the second study (61%, SD 4%, versus 47%, SD 5%, P less than .05); it was restricted to the FAB types M1 through M4 (EFI: 67%, SD 5%, versus 45%, SD 5%, P less than .01). The difference in EFI seen in FAB M5 was not statistically significant (EFI: 40%, SD 10%, versus 63%, SD 11%, NS). According to the results of the second study, two different risk groups (low and high) could be identified by combinations of predominantly pretherapeutic parameters. The low risk group, comprising 37% of the patients who achieved complete remission, included the FAB types with granulocytic differentiation and specific additional features: FAB M1 with Auer rods, FAB M2 with white blood cell count of less than 20,000/microL, FAB M3 all patients, and FAB M4 with eosinophilia. The 6-year Kaplan-Meier estimation of EFI is 91%, SD 4%, compared with 42%, SD 6% in the high risk group. In future studies based on the AML-BFM-83 treatment, bone marrow transplantation in first remission should be mandatory only for children of the high risk group.
两项关于儿童急性髓性白血病治疗的合作研究(AML - BFM - 78和AML - BFM - 83)之间的主要区别在于,第二项研究增加了为期8天的ADE(阿糖胞苷、柔红霉素、依托泊苷)诱导治疗。由于这种强化治疗,复发率降低了,但诱导失败率未降低。6年无事件生存率从AML - BFM - 78研究中的38%(标准差4%)提高到AML - BFM - 83研究中的49%(标准差4%),P = 0.08。第二项研究中6年无事件间隔(EFI)的改善具有显著性(61%,标准差4%,对比47%,标准差5%,P小于0.05);这种改善仅限于FAB分型M1至M4(EFI:67%,标准差5%,对比45%,标准差5%,P小于0.01)。FAB M5中观察到的EFI差异无统计学意义(EFI:40%,标准差10%,对比63%,标准差11%,无显著性差异)。根据第二项研究的结果,通过主要治疗前参数的组合可以识别出两个不同的风险组(低风险和高风险)。低风险组包括37%达到完全缓解的患者,包括具有粒细胞分化和特定附加特征的FAB分型:有奥氏小体的FAB M1、白细胞计数低于20,000/微升的FAB M2、所有FAB M3患者以及伴有嗜酸性粒细胞增多的FAB M4。6年的EFI的Kaplan - Meier估计值为91%,标准差4%,而高风险组为42%,标准差6%。在未来基于AML - BFM - 83治疗的研究中,仅对高风险组的儿童在首次缓解期进行骨髓移植应成为强制性措施。