Department of Neurology Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
Clin EEG Neurosci. 2011 Jul;42(3):202-5. doi: 10.1177/155005941104200311.
It is well established that convulsive movements often accompany syncopal events yet many patients with these clinical features are misdiagnosed with seizures and often referred to epilepsy centers because they are refractory to treatment with anticonvulsant medications. Tilt table testing is the gold standard for diagnosing vasodepressor syncope, but it can fail to provide clinical details that help distinguish convulsive syncope from epileptic seizures and psychogenic events. This study evaluates the diagnostic utility of the addition of video and EEG monitoring during tilt table testing for patients with refractory episodes of unexplained loss of consciousness. Retrospective analysis was performed of 40 consecutive patients who were referred to the Emory Epilepsy Center and underwent tilt table testing with concomitant video-EEG between March 1, 2007 and December 1, 2008. EEG was recorded throughout the study in addition to video recording and single channel EKG. Events were classified as vasodepressor syncope, presyncope, or psychogenic. Tilt combined with video EEG was diagnostic in 26/40 (65%) of patients. Vasodepressor syncope was seen in 17/40 (42.5%), 9 of which had associated involuntary movements. Three patients experienced psychogenic non-epileptic events. Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) were being prescribed for 17 patients, 7 of which were discontinued as a result of the testing. The majority of patients (38/40) had undergone prior neurological and cardiac evaluation with routine EEG, neuroimaging and/or Holter monitoring. Patients with convulsive syncope are often misdiagnosed and treated with AEDs despite prior neurodiagnostic and cardiac evaluation. Tilt table testing with video-EEG is useful in patients with refractory episodes of unexplained loss of consciousness and can avoid expensive non-diagnostic evaluations as well as ongoing treatment with unnecessary AEDs.
众所周知,抽搐通常伴随着晕厥事件,但许多具有这些临床特征的患者被误诊为癫痫发作,并且由于对抗癫痫药物治疗无反应,经常被转诊到癫痫中心。倾斜台测试是诊断血管迷走性晕厥的金标准,但它可能无法提供有助于区分抽搐性晕厥与癫痫发作和心因性事件的临床细节。本研究评估了在倾斜台测试中添加视频和 EEG 监测对难治性不明原因意识丧失患者的诊断效用。回顾性分析了 2007 年 3 月 1 日至 2008 年 12 月 1 日期间因难治性不明原因意识丧失而被转介到埃默里癫痫中心并接受倾斜台测试和同期视频-EEG 的 40 例连续患者。除了视频记录和单通道心电图外,整个研究期间都记录了 EEG。事件被分类为血管迷走性晕厥、晕厥前或心因性。倾斜台联合视频 EEG 在 40 例中的 26 例(65%)中具有诊断价值。40 例中,血管迷走性晕厥 17 例(42.5%),其中 9 例伴有不自主运动。3 例患者经历了心因性非癫痫发作。17 例患者正在服用抗癫痫药物(AEDs),其中 7 例因测试而停药。大多数患者(40 例中的 38 例)已经接受了常规 EEG、神经影像学和/或动态心电图监测的神经和心脏评估。尽管先前进行了神经诊断和心脏评估,伴有抽搐性晕厥的患者仍经常被误诊并接受 AED 治疗。倾斜台测试联合视频 EEG 对难治性不明原因意识丧失患者有用,可以避免昂贵的非诊断性评估以及不必要的 AED 持续治疗。