Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Rothman Institute Orthopaedics, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Arthroscopy. 2011 Oct;27(10):1422-33. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2011.06.006. Epub 2011 Aug 26.
The gold standard of treatment for glenohumeral instability has traditionally been viewed as open shoulder stabilization. With the increased awareness of complex instability patterns and the ability to preoperatively detect concomitant pathology with advanced imaging modalities, an evidence-based shift to an all-arthroscopic approach to shoulder stabilization surgery is occurring. Current data suggest that patients who meet eligibility criteria for arthroscopic stabilization (those without significant bony lesions or significant deformity) can expect equivalent rates of recurrence, better functional outcomes, and less morbidity. Modern arthroscopic techniques using suture anchors and capsular plication have resulted in a significant improvement over previous reports in the orthopaedic literature. An argument is put forth on the benefits of an all-arthroscopic approach to shoulder stabilization in athletes and nonathletes alike based on a review of the current orthopaedic literature comparing the evolved arthroscopic technique with more traditional open methods.
对于肩锁关节不稳定的治疗,金标准一直被视为开放式肩部稳定。随着对复杂不稳定模式的认识不断提高,以及术前利用先进的影像学手段来检测伴随病理的能力不断提高,一种基于循证医学的转变正在发生,即将全关节镜入路应用于肩锁关节稳定手术。目前的数据表明,符合关节镜稳定术适应证的患者(无明显骨病变或明显畸形的患者)可预期复发率相当、更好的功能结果和更低的发病率。使用缝合锚和囊瓣紧缩的现代关节镜技术与骨科文献中的先前报告相比,取得了显著的进步。通过回顾比较现有关节镜技术与更传统的开放式方法的骨科文献,提出了在运动员和非运动员中采用全关节镜入路进行肩锁关节稳定的优势。