Department of Dermatology and Allergy, Allergy Centre Charité, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Charitéplatz 1, 10117 Berlin, Germany.
Inflamm Res. 2011 Dec;60(12):1107-12. doi: 10.1007/s00011-011-0373-y. Epub 2011 Aug 28.
Comparison of bilastine and cetirizine in inhibiting skin wheal and flare responses over 24 h.
Twenty-one healthy male volunteers (aged 19-44 years).
Volunteers were randomised to receive single oral doses of 20 or 50 mg bilastine, 10 mg cetirizine or placebo before provocation of wheal and flare responses to 100 mg/ml histamine by skin prick 1.5, 4, 8, 12 and 24 h later.
There were no significant differences between overall inhibitions of wheal or flare by 20 mg bilastine and 10 mg cetirizine. Bilastine was faster in onset than cetirizine, inhibitions of wheal and flare at 1.5 h being 89 ± 3 versus 44 ± 14% (P = 0.011) and 85 ± 4 versus 45 ± 14% (P = 0.016), respectively (Student's t test). At 1.5 h, both wheals and flares were inhibited by >70% in 11/12 volunteers taking bilastine and 3/11 taking cetirizine (P = 0.003, Fisher's exact test). There were no significant differences between the drugs at later times. Bilastine 50 mg had a longer duration of action than bilastine 20 mg.
Both 20 mg bilastine and 10 mg cetirizine are effective and of long duration in reducing histamine-induced wheal and flare responses, the major difference between the two drugs being the more rapid onset of action of bilastine.
比较比拉斯汀和西替利嗪在 24 小时内抑制皮肤风团和红斑反应。
21 名健康男性志愿者(年龄 19-44 岁)。
志愿者随机接受单次口服 20 或 50mg 比拉斯汀、10mg 西替利嗪或安慰剂,然后在 1.5、4、8、12 和 24 小时后通过皮肤划痕对 100mg/ml 组胺进行风团和红斑反应激发。
20mg 比拉斯汀和 10mg 西替利嗪对风团或红斑的总体抑制作用无显著差异。比拉斯汀的起效速度快于西替利嗪,1.5 小时时风团和红斑的抑制率分别为 89±3%比 44±14%(P=0.011)和 85±4%比 45±14%(P=0.016)(Student's t 检验)。在 1.5 小时时,12 名服用比拉斯汀的志愿者中有 11 名(89%),11 名服用西替利嗪的志愿者中有 3 名(27%)的风团和红斑抑制率>70%(P=0.003,Fisher 确切检验)。在随后的时间点,两种药物之间无显著差异。比拉斯汀 50mg 的作用持续时间长于比拉斯汀 20mg。
20mg 比拉斯汀和 10mg 西替利嗪均有效且作用时间长,可减少组胺诱导的风团和红斑反应,两种药物的主要区别在于比拉斯汀的作用更快。