Frantzen Durant, San Miguel Claudia, Kwak Dae-Hoon
Department of Arts and Sciences, Texas A&M University-San Antonio, TX 78224, USA.
Violence Vict. 2011;26(4):395-409. doi: 10.1891/0886-6708.26.4.395.
Previous research offered little guidance on sentencing outcomes for protection order (PO) violations in cases of domestic assault and whether PO violation charges affected offender recidivism rates. Using data from local court records, this study examined the effect of PO violation charges on the odds of case conviction relative to dismissal, and whether case conviction or a PO violation charge results in lower domestic violence rearrest rates compared to offenders not receiving these sanctions. The models indicate that PO violation charges has no significant effect on the odds of conviction or recidivism rates, and these trends were not significantly different for convicted versus dismissed offenders. Findings are discussed in relation to previous research with recommendations for future areas of study.
先前的研究对于家庭攻击案件中违反保护令(PO)的量刑结果以及违反保护令的指控是否会影响罪犯的累犯率几乎没有提供指导。本研究利用当地法庭记录中的数据,考察了违反保护令的指控相对于驳回指控对案件定罪几率的影响,以及与未受到这些制裁的罪犯相比,案件定罪或违反保护令的指控是否会导致更低的家庭暴力再次逮捕率。模型表明,违反保护令的指控对定罪几率或累犯率没有显著影响,并且这些趋势在被定罪者与被驳回指控者之间没有显著差异。结合先前的研究对研究结果进行了讨论,并对未来的研究领域提出了建议。