Glazier H S
Department of Pharmacy Services, University Hospitals of Cleveland, OH 44106.
DICP. 1990 May;24(5):484-8. doi: 10.1177/106002809002400509.
Opioid analgesics are among the oldest known medications. In spite of long usage, clinical success in controlling pain in many settings appears to be limited by a lack of understanding of the clinical pharmacology of these agents. Efforts to achieve better outcomes often focus on the use of adjunctive agents, such as hydroxyzine, in an attempt to control postoperative pain with a minimum of toxicity. Although such combined therapies are exceedingly common, clinical data supporting a hypothesis of an "opioid-sparing" effect of hydroxyzine are marked by serious methodologic flaws, including lack of placebo control, lack of statistical analyses, and use of subjective assessments, all of which compromise the validity of such conclusions. In doses that may contribute to pain relief, hydroxyzine demonstrates a significant potential for causing respiratory depression which is additive to that of opioids, but not reversible with naloxone. In total, the data do not confirm the purported clinical benefits of hydroxyzine-opioid combinations in comparison with appropriate regimens of opioids alone.
阿片类镇痛药是已知最古老的药物之一。尽管使用时间很长,但在许多情况下,由于对这些药物的临床药理学缺乏了解,控制疼痛的临床效果似乎有限。为了取得更好的效果,人们常常致力于使用辅助药物,如羟嗪,试图以最小的毒性控制术后疼痛。尽管这种联合疗法极为常见,但支持羟嗪具有“节省阿片类药物”作用这一假设的临床数据存在严重的方法学缺陷,包括缺乏安慰剂对照、缺乏统计分析以及使用主观评估,所有这些都损害了此类结论的有效性。在可能有助于缓解疼痛的剂量下,羟嗪显示出导致呼吸抑制的显著可能性,这种呼吸抑制与阿片类药物的呼吸抑制作用相加,但不能被纳洛酮逆转。总体而言,与单独使用适当的阿片类药物方案相比,数据并未证实羟嗪 - 阿片类药物联合使用所宣称的临床益处。