School of Dental Hygiene, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada.
Int J Dent Hyg. 2012 May;10(2):91-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1601-5037.2011.00520.x. Epub 2011 Sep 17.
Policymakers worldwide are challenged by the problem of oral health inequities. The goal of an interprovincial partnership in Canada was to guide policy aimed at improving the oral health of vulnerable populations. Insights regarding barriers and enablers to developing such policy in one province (Newfoundland & Labrador, Canada) were required to enhance collaboration between decision makers and researchers and to contribute to the evidence informing policy development.
Snowball technique identified fourteen key informants. Semistructured audio-recorded interviews were conducted in person or by telephone. Two researchers independently conducted the analyses of the transcribed interviews, one using NVivo software and the second, manual coding. Triangulation of the analyses confirmed the findings.
Agreement between the two approaches showed that most key informants believed that oral health is an important policy issue; however, most felt it was not a high priority among the general public and most were unable to articulate the policy process. Barriers to oral health becoming a governmental priority were related to resource allocation and to poor communication among some groups including dentists and dental hygienists. Current government programmes and initiatives were praised but considered weak in health promotion strategies. Recommendations for enhancing oral health priority varied.
Attention to the methodological considerations of qualitative research enhanced the credibility of the method and confidence in the findings. Leveraging of existing programmes and improving communication were recommended to contribute to raising the priority of oral health within the government, thereby increasing their commitment to address oral health care, particularly for vulnerable populations.
全球政策制定者都面临着口腔健康不平等的问题。加拿大一个跨省合作伙伴关系的目标是为旨在改善弱势群体口腔健康的政策提供指导。需要了解一个省份(加拿大纽芬兰和拉布拉多省)制定此类政策的障碍和促进因素,以加强决策者和研究人员之间的合作,并为政策制定提供证据。
滚雪球技术确定了 14 名关键信息提供者。采用面对面或电话方式进行半结构式音频记录访谈。两名研究人员分别独立对转录后的访谈进行分析,一名使用 NVivo 软件,另一名手动编码。分析结果的三角验证证实了研究结果。
两种方法之间的一致性表明,大多数关键信息提供者认为口腔健康是一个重要的政策问题;然而,大多数人认为公众对此并不是高度重视,而且大多数人无法说明政策制定的过程。口腔健康成为政府优先事项的障碍与资源分配以及包括牙医和口腔卫生师在内的一些群体之间沟通不畅有关。目前的政府方案和举措受到了赞扬,但在健康促进策略方面被认为较弱。增强口腔健康优先事项的建议各不相同。
对定性研究方法学考虑因素的关注增强了方法的可信度和对研究结果的信心。建议利用现有的方案并改善沟通,以提高政府对口腔健康的重视程度,从而增加他们解决口腔保健问题的承诺,特别是为弱势群体。