Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Kwandong University College of Medicine, Goyang, South Korea.
PLoS One. 2011;6(9):e24511. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0024511. Epub 2011 Sep 13.
Otologic manifestations are one of the most consistent findings of CHARGE syndrome found in more than 90%. Since genetic analysis of the CHD7 gene has rarely been performed in previous reports dealing with ear abnormalities, the genotypic spectrum of CHD7 mutations was analyzed in deaf patients with CHARGE syndrome, and the clinical considerations concerning auditory rehabilitation were investigated.
Nine Korean patients with CHARGE syndrome showing profound hearing loss and semicircular canal aplasia were included. All 38 exons of CHD7 were analyzed by direct sequencing. For splice site variations, in silico and exon-trapping analyses were performed to verify the pathogenicity of nucleotide variations. Clinical features and the outcome of auditory rehabilitation were also analyzed.
Eight of 9 patients revealed alterations of the CHD7 gene including 3 frameshift, 2 nonsense, 2 splice site, and 1 missense mutations. Five of 9 patients were clinically diagnosed as atypical CHARGE syndrome but demonstrated various mutations of the CHD7 gene. One familial case showed intra-familial variability. Radiologic findings suggesting cochleovestibular nerve deficiency were identified in most of the patients. Of the 8 patients who underwent cochlear implantation, 5 patients demonstrated favorable outcome. Larger diameter of the cochleovestibular nerve on imaging and absence of severe mental retardation were factors related to better outcome after cochlear implantation rather than the type of CHD7 mutations. Auditory brainstem implantation was performed in two patients who did not benefit from cochlear implantation.
Genetic analysis of the CHD7 gene should be performed in cases with semicircular canal aplasia even when other typical features of CHARGE syndrome are absent. For auditory rehabilitation in CHARGE syndrome, cochlear implantation should be strongly recommended in selected cases with favorable prognostic factors. Auditory brainstem implantation may be a viable option in patients with CHARGE syndrome who have failed to benefit from cochlear implantation.
耳科表现是 CHARGE 综合征最一致的发现之一,超过 90%的患者存在该表现。由于以前关于耳部异常的报道中很少对 CHD7 基因进行基因分析,因此对 CHARGE 综合征伴耳聋患者进行 CHD7 基因突变的基因型谱分析,并探讨听觉康复的临床注意事项。
纳入 9 例韩国 CHARGE 综合征患者,表现为重度听力损失和半规管发育不全。通过直接测序分析 CHD7 的所有 38 个外显子。对于剪接位点变异,通过计算机预测和外显子捕获分析来验证核苷酸变异的致病性。分析临床特征和听觉康复的结果。
9 例患者中有 8 例发现 CHD7 基因改变,包括 3 种移码突变、2 种无义突变、2 种剪接位点突变和 1 种错义突变。9 例患者中有 5 例临床诊断为非典型 CHARGE 综合征,但表现出 CHD7 基因突变的多样性。1 例家族性病例表现出家族内变异性。大多数患者的影像学检查均提示蜗神经-前庭神经发育不良。在接受人工耳蜗植入术的 8 例患者中,5 例患者的结果较好。影像学上蜗神经-前庭神经直径较大,且无严重智力障碍,是人工耳蜗植入术后结果较好的相关因素,而与 CHD7 基因突变类型无关。2 例未从人工耳蜗植入中获益的患者进行了听觉脑干植入术。
即使 CHARGE 综合征的其他典型特征不存在,对于半规管发育不全的患者也应进行 CHD7 基因分析。对于 CHARGE 综合征的听觉康复,在有良好预后因素的情况下,强烈推荐对选定病例进行人工耳蜗植入。对于未能从人工耳蜗植入中获益的 CHARGE 综合征患者,听觉脑干植入可能是一种可行的选择。