Faller Emilie, Tunon de Lara Christine, Fournier Marion, Brouste Véronique, Mathoulin-Pélissier Simone, Bussières Emmanuel, De Mascarel Isabelle, Macgrogan Gaëtan
Université Bordeaux Segalen, France.
Bull Cancer. 2011 Oct;98(9):1047-57. doi: 10.1684/bdc.2011.1433.
Intraoperative examination of sentinel lymph nodes (SLN) in breast cancer can avoid a new surgical procedure in case of positive SLN, but its value, efficacy and the methods used are still controversial. The aim of our study was to evaluate the imprint cytology intraoperative method of SLN analysis performed at our institution. We did a retrospective study of the sentinel lymph node procedures performed during a period of 24 months on cT1N0 unifocal breast cancers. Intraoperative procedure was mainly by imprint cytology (touch prep). A SLN procedure was performed on 187 women with 360 SLN. Two hundred and seventy-seven SLN among 156 women were analyzed intraoperatively by touch prep. 19/48 positive SLN were detected by intraoperative touch prep (sensitivity 39.6%; specificity 100%; positive predictive value 100%; negative predictive value 88.7%, accuracy 89.5%). False negative rate of cytological intraoperative examination of SLN was 11,2% by SLN and 18,3% by patient. By univariate analysis, this rate significantly increased with lymphovascular invasion, tumor size cT1b and c and histological SBR grade 2 or 3. By multivariate analysis, only lymphovascular invasion was a predictive factor of intraoperative touch prep failure (OR = 3.3; IC 1.3-8.4). Intraoperative imprint cytology of SLN in breast cancer is associated with a high rate of false negativity that questions its use in this setting.
乳腺癌前哨淋巴结(SLN)的术中检查可在SLN阳性时避免再次手术,但该检查的价值、疗效及所用方法仍存在争议。我们研究的目的是评估在本机构进行的SLN分析术中印片细胞学方法。我们对24个月期间对cT1N0单灶性乳腺癌患者进行的前哨淋巴结手术进行了回顾性研究。术中主要采用印片细胞学检查(触摸涂片)。对187例女性患者的360枚SLN进行了前哨淋巴结手术。156例女性患者中的277枚SLN术中通过触摸涂片进行分析。术中触摸涂片检测出19/48枚阳性SLN(敏感性39.6%;特异性100%;阳性预测值100%;阴性预测值88.7%,准确率89.5%)。SLN术中细胞学检查的假阴性率按SLN计算为11.2%,按患者计算为18.3%。单因素分析显示,该比率随淋巴管浸润、肿瘤大小cT1b和c以及组织学SBR 2级或3级显著增加。多因素分析显示,只有淋巴管浸润是术中触摸涂片失败的预测因素(OR = 3.3;95%置信区间1.3 - 8.4)。乳腺癌SLN术中印片细胞学检查假阴性率较高,这对其在该情况下的应用提出了质疑。