National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.
J Nutr. 2011 Nov;141(11):2055-63. doi: 10.3945/jn.111.142398. Epub 2011 Sep 28.
Statistical modeling of habitual micronutrient intake from food and dietary supplements using short-term measurements is hampered by heterogeneous variances and multimodality. Summing short-term intakes from food and dietary supplements prior to simple correction for within-person variation (first add then shrink) may produce estimates of habitual total micronutrient intake so badly biased as to be smaller than estimates of habitual intake from food sources only. A 3-part model using a first shrink then add approach is proposed to estimate the habitual micronutrient intake from food among nonsupplement users, food among supplement users, and supplements. The population distribution of habitual total micronutrient intake is estimated by combining these 3 habitual intake distributions, accounting for possible interdependence between Eq. 2 and 3. The new model is an extension of a model developed by the USA National Cancer Institute. Habitual total vitamin D intake among young children was estimated using the proposed model and data from the Dutch food consumption survey (n = 1279). The model always produced habitual total intakes similar to or higher than habitual intakes from food sources only and also preserved the multimodal shape of the observed total vitamin D intake distribution. This proposed method incorporates several sources of covariate information that should provide more precise estimates of the habitual total intake distribution and the proportion of the population with intakes below/above cutpoint values. The proposed methodology could be useful for other complex situations, e.g. where high concentrations of micronutrients appear in episodically consumed foods.
使用短期测量来对习惯性微量营养素摄入(来自食物和膳食补充剂)进行统计建模会受到异方差和多峰性的阻碍。在简单校正个体内变异(先加后缩)之前对食物和膳食补充剂的短期摄入量进行求和,可能会导致习惯性总微量营养素摄入量的估计值严重偏差,以至于小于仅来自食物来源的习惯性摄入量的估计值。本文提出了一种 3 部分模型,采用先缩后加的方法来估计非补充使用者的食物中习惯性微量营养素摄入、补充使用者的补充剂中习惯性微量营养素摄入和补充剂中的习惯性微量营养素摄入。通过将这 3 个习惯性摄入分布结合起来,估计习惯性总微量营养素摄入的人群分布,同时考虑到等式 2 和 3 之间可能存在的相互依赖性。该新模型是美国国家癌症研究所开发的模型的扩展。使用所提出的模型和荷兰食物消费调查(n=1279)的数据,估计了幼儿习惯性总维生素 D 摄入。该模型始终产生与仅来自食物来源的习惯性总摄入量相似或更高的习惯性总摄入量,并且保留了观察到的总维生素 D 摄入量分布的多峰形状。该方法结合了几种协变量信息来源,应能更精确地估计习惯性总摄入量分布和摄入量低于/高于切点值的人群比例。该方法可用于其他复杂情况,例如,在某些情况下,微量营养素浓度高,且仅出现在间歇性摄入的食物中。