Department of Public Health, HSE-Mid West, Mount Kennett House, Henry Street, Limerick, Ireland.
Ir J Med Sci. 2012 Jun;181(2):199-204. doi: 10.1007/s11845-011-0773-6. Epub 2011 Oct 20.
Multiple sclerosis is the commonest cause of disability in young Irish adults. Natalizumab reduces disability progression in those patients with relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis who are suitable for it. First line disease modifying therapies are given in the community and are paid for by the hi-tech drug scheme. Natalizumab is given in hospital and is paid for from the hospital's budget. Access to natalizumab has been problematic in some Irish hospitals. A budget impact analysis was performed to look at the overall cost to the Health Service Executive of giving natalizumab.
A budget impact analysis was performed from the perspective of the Health Service Executive comparing the use of natalizumab with first line disease modifying therapies for 2009-2011.
The study showed that currently, the use of natalizumab is likely to be cost saving to the Health Service Executive overall, because some of the costs for natalizumab are borne by private insurers, whereas, all of the costs of disease modifying therapies are borne by the Health Service Executive.
Although the use of natalizumab is cost saving, current funding arrangements in the Health Service Executive do not allow for the transfer of money saved from drugs paid for in the hi-tech scheme, to hospitals who are supplying alternative treatments.
多发性硬化症是爱尔兰年轻成年人中最常见的致残原因。那他珠单抗可减少适合使用该药的复发缓解型多发性硬化症患者的残疾进展。一线疾病修正疗法在社区中使用,由高科技药物计划支付。那他珠单抗在医院使用,由医院预算支付。在一些爱尔兰医院,那他珠单抗的使用存在问题。进行了一项预算影响分析,以评估为健康服务行政部门提供那他珠单抗的总成本。
从健康服务行政部门的角度进行预算影响分析,比较了 2009 年至 2011 年使用那他珠单抗与一线疾病修正疗法的情况。
研究表明,目前,那他珠单抗的使用对健康服务行政部门总体上可能具有成本节约效益,因为那他珠单抗的部分成本由私人保险公司承担,而疾病修正疗法的所有成本均由健康服务行政部门承担。
尽管使用那他珠单抗具有成本节约效益,但健康服务行政部门当前的资金安排不允许将从高科技计划支付的药物节省的资金转移给提供替代治疗的医院。