Mannella Riccardo
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine of l'Università di Pisa, Italy.
J Vet Med Educ. 2011 Summer;38(2):184-93. doi: 10.3138/jvme.38.2.184.
The present paper analyzes the admission test administered to candidates to the veterinary medicine program in Italy for the academic years 2007-2008, 2008-2009, and 2009-2010 nationwide as well as the University of Pisa student intake from 2001-2002 through 2009-2010, comparing the relationship between the admission test and students' academic careers at Pisa. This paper finds that the Italian system of a locally enforced fixed intake number does not select the best possible candidates for admission because (1) there are significant variations in the candidates' preparation among the different locations where the test is held, (2) the subjects tested are not equally selective in identifying the best candidates, and (3) there is a very strong relationship between candidates' performance on the admission test and the subsequent academic career of the admitted candidates. In its findings, this study in part contradicts what is commonly believed by the Italian veterinary medicine community, and, as a result, it is extremely important that care is taken in the decision-making process-in the process, that is, of identifying a fixed intake number and of selecting the subjects to be tested on the admission test.
本文分析了2007 - 2008学年、2008 - 2009学年和2009 - 2010学年在意大利全国范围内针对兽医学专业考生进行的入学考试,以及比萨大学2001 - 2002年至2009 - 2010年的学生录取情况,比较了入学考试与比萨大学学生学业生涯之间的关系。本文发现,意大利当地强制规定固定录取人数的制度未能选拔出最优秀的入学候选人,原因如下:(1)在举行考试的不同地点,考生的准备情况存在显著差异;(2)所考科目在甄别最优秀候选人方面的选拔性并不相同;(3)考生在入学考试中的表现与被录取考生随后的学业生涯之间存在非常紧密的关系。在其研究结果中,本研究部分地与意大利兽医学界的普遍看法相矛盾,因此,在决策过程中——即在确定固定录取人数以及选择入学考试所考科目的过程中——务必谨慎行事,这一点极其重要。