Department of Anatomy, College of Basic Medical Science Third Military Medical University, Chongqing, China.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2012 Sep;21(9):1207-12. doi: 10.1016/j.jse.2011.07.026. Epub 2011 Nov 1.
Although the incidence of osteoarticular tuberculosis is increasing, glenohumeral joint tuberculosis is rare and often misdiagnosed in its early stages. Our objective was to study the incidence of the initial misdiagnosis as frozen shoulder and the duration of the prediagnostic period among patients with glenohumeral joint tuberculosis.
The clinical records of 21 patients with tuberculosis of the shoulder joint were retrospectively analyzed.
Among the 16 patients with glenohumeral joint tuberculosis, 14 (87.5%) were initially diagnosed as having frozen shoulder instead of glenohumeral joint tuberculosis at their primary care clinics. Two patients actually showed both shoulder pain and limited range of motion, although they did not have a record of initial diagnosis with frozen shoulder. Consequently, 14 (87.5%) of the patients in our study with glenohumeral joint tuberculosis were likely misdiagnosed as having frozen shoulder. On the other hand, this group accounted for 3.6% (n = 16) of 450 patients who, during the same period, had been initially diagnosed with frozen shoulder at our institution. The mean prediagnostic period to attain the final, correct diagnosis of glenohumeral joint tuberculosis for this group was 14.5 months.
It appears that misdiagnosis is common and early diagnosis of tubercular infection in the glenohumeral joint has become increasingly difficult. Glenohumeral joint tuberculosis should be suspected in cases of longstanding pain in the shoulder. It is necessary to re-examine these frozen shoulder patients with repeated plain radiographs followed by further imaging studies, especially magnetic resonance imaging, if conservative therapy fails.
尽管骨与关节结核的发病率正在增加,但盂肱关节结核较为罕见,且在早期常被误诊。我们的目的是研究盂肱关节结核患者初始误诊为冻结肩的发生率和诊断前时间。
回顾性分析 21 例肩关节结核患者的临床资料。
16 例盂肱关节结核患者中,14 例(87.5%)在初级保健诊所最初被误诊为冻结肩而非盂肱关节结核。两名患者实际上均有肩部疼痛和活动范围受限,但他们并没有最初被诊断为冻结肩的记录。因此,我们研究中的 14 例(87.5%)盂肱关节结核患者可能被误诊为冻结肩。另一方面,这组患者占同期我院最初被诊断为冻结肩的 450 例患者的 3.6%(n=16)。该组患者达到盂肱关节结核最终正确诊断的平均诊断前时间为 14.5 个月。
看来误诊很常见,盂肱关节结核的早期诊断变得越来越困难。对于长期肩部疼痛的患者,应怀疑为结核感染。如果保守治疗失败,有必要对这些冻结肩患者进行重复的平片检查,并进一步进行影像学研究,尤其是磁共振成像检查。