Health Policy and Management, York University, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Health Promot Int. 2013 Mar;28(1):112-32. doi: 10.1093/heapro/dar058. Epub 2011 Nov 3.
Governmental authorities of wealthy developed nations differ in their professed commitments and activity related to the provision of the prerequisites of health through public policy action. Part 1 of this article showed how nations identified as social democratic or liberal welfare states were those where such commitments are present. Nations identified as conservative or Latin welfare states were less likely to express such commitments. However, the political economy literature suggests that despite their expressed commitments to provision of the prerequisites of health, liberal welfare states fare rather poorly in implementing these commitments. The opposite is seen for conservative welfare states. Social democratic welfare states show both commitments and public policy consistent with this objective. Part 2 of this article documents the extent to which public policy activity that provides the prerequisites of health through public policy action differs among varying welfare state regimes. Despite extensive rhetoric concerning the prerequisites of health, nations identified as liberal welfare states do a rather poor job of meeting these goals and show evidence of adverse health outcomes. In contrast, social democratic welfare states fare better in providing such prerequisites--consistent with their rhetorical statements--with better health outcomes. Interestingly, conservative--and to a lesser extent Latin--nations fare well in providing the prerequisites of health despite their lack of explicit commitment to such concepts. Findings suggest that health promoters have to concern themselves with the broad strokes of public policymaking whether or not these policy activities are identified as health promotion activities.
富裕发达国家的政府当局在通过公共政策行动提供健康先决条件方面的公开承诺和相关活动存在差异。本文第一部分展示了被确定为社会民主或自由福利国家的国家如何存在这些承诺。被确定为保守或拉丁福利国家的国家不太可能表达这种承诺。然而,政治经济学文献表明,尽管这些国家表示承诺提供健康先决条件,但自由福利国家在实施这些承诺方面表现相当差。相反,保守福利国家则不然。社会民主福利国家表现出符合这一目标的承诺和公共政策。本文第二部分记录了通过公共政策行动提供健康先决条件的公共政策活动在不同福利国家制度之间存在差异的程度。尽管有大量关于健康先决条件的言论,但被确定为自由福利国家的国家在实现这些目标方面做得相当差,并显示出不良健康结果的证据。相比之下,社会民主福利国家在提供这些先决条件方面表现更好,与他们的言论声明一致,并且有更好的健康结果。有趣的是,尽管保守主义国家(以及在较小程度上的拉丁国家)缺乏对这些概念的明确承诺,但它们在提供健康先决条件方面表现出色。研究结果表明,健康促进者必须关注公共决策的广泛方面,无论这些政策活动是否被确定为健康促进活动。