Department of Otorhinolaryngology and Logopaedic & Audiologic Sciences, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Am J Med Genet A. 2011 Dec;155A(12):2974-81. doi: 10.1002/ajmg.a.34314. Epub 2011 Nov 3.
When characterizing the speech of a patient with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1), hypernasality is often mentioned. As few studies applied technically assisted evaluations of nasality in NF1 patients, the aim of the present study was to document the nasal resonance of adults with NF1 using nasometry. The nasometric data obtained from the NF1 patients were compared with the nasalance scores of a healthy control group and with normative data. The final study group consisted of 24 adult NF1 patients and 16 controls, all living in the East Flemish part of Belgium. Nasalance scores were obtained while the participants sustained three vowels (/a:/, /i./, and /u./) and one consonant (/m/) and read three standard nasalance passages. Despite the inter- and intra-subject variability, we observed that NF1 patients as a group exhibited higher mean nasalance scores than controls. This finding was especially clear in males. Potential genotype-phenotype correlations between NF1 mutation type and hypernasality were examined but could not be demonstrated. Conversely, comparison of the nasometric data obtained from the NF1 patients with magnetic resonance imaging findings showed some degree of interesting correlation. We conclude that, notwithstanding the small sample size for some analyses, nasality is an area of interest in the NF1 population. As altered nasality influences speech intelligibility, nasality requires attention during follow-up visits, particularly when it concerns a male NF1 patient.
在描述 1 型神经纤维瘤病(NF1)患者的言语特征时,常提到高鼻音。由于很少有研究应用技术辅助评估 NF1 患者的鼻音,因此本研究旨在使用鼻音计记录 NF1 成人的鼻腔共鸣。将从 NF1 患者获得的鼻音计数据与健康对照组的鼻音值进行比较,并与正常值进行比较。最终的研究组包括 24 名成年 NF1 患者和 16 名对照组,他们均居住在比利时东佛兰德省。参与者在维持三个元音(/a:/、/i./ 和 /u./)和一个辅音(/m/)并朗读三个标准鼻音段落时获得鼻音值。尽管存在个体间和个体内的变异性,但我们观察到 NF1 患者组的平均鼻音值高于对照组。这一发现在男性中尤为明显。虽然检查了 NF1 突变类型与高鼻音之间的潜在基因型-表型相关性,但未能证明其存在。相反,将 NF1 患者的鼻音计数据与磁共振成像结果进行比较显示出一定程度的有趣相关性。我们得出结论,尽管某些分析的样本量较小,但鼻音是 NF1 人群中值得关注的一个领域。由于改变的鼻音会影响言语清晰度,因此在随访就诊时需要注意鼻音,尤其是当涉及到男性 NF1 患者时。