Food Science Australia, P.O. Box 3312, Tingalpa D. C., QLD. 4173, Australia.
Meat Sci. 2004 Jun;67(2):261-8. doi: 10.1016/j.meatsci.2003.10.014.
Beef from cattle finished on grass will be of similar quality to that from cattle finished on grain when their carcasses are processed using best practice protocols. To test this hypothesis, carcasses of twenty Brahman steers, finished to 400 kg live weight on either Buffel grass pasture (n=10) or grain (n=10), were electrically stimulated with 400 V for 50 s 45 min postmortem, and their beef quality assessed 1 and 14 days postmortem. Hot weight, rump subcutaneous fat thickness and animal rate of growth in the 205 days preceding slaughter were recorded for each carcass as potential influences on beef quality. Quality of the M. longissimus thoracis (LT) at 1 and 14 days postmortem was evaluated using peak Warner-Bratzler shear force, compression, pH, cooking loss and taste panel acceptability, as well as by moisture and crude fat contents measured at 1 day postmortem. Results showed that steers finished on pasture grew the slowest and had the least subcutaneous fat at the same carcass weight. LT from carcasses of steers finished on pasture also had the shortest mean sarcomere lengths, suggesting these muscles may have been cold-affected, but there was no effect of diet on peak shear force. LT from carcasses of steers finished on pasture had the highest mean compression value, possibly because of increased collagen cross-linking associated with slow growth or increased exercise. Ageing significantly decreased LT peak shear force and compression values and increased cooking loss, L (∗), a (∗) and b (∗) values. Taste panellists rated the aged, grass-finished beef the most tender and the best quality; however, the taste panel in this study may have favoured LT from grass-finished steers because it was significantly juicier than LT from the grain-finished steer carcasses. These results indicated that carcass composition and processing conditions interact to exert a greater effect on LT toughness and sensory acceptability than finishing diet. Ageing LT from steers finished on grass improved its colour, and thus may enhance its consumer acceptability.
当使用最佳实践方案对使用草饲育肥和谷物育肥的牛的胴体进行处理时,草饲牛肉的品质将与谷物育肥牛肉的品质相似。为了验证这一假设,对 20 头婆罗门阉牛进行了试验,每头阉牛的体重达到 400 公斤时结束育肥,其中 10 头阉牛在布法罗草牧场育肥,10 头阉牛在谷物上育肥。在宰后 45 分钟,用 400V 对牛进行 50 秒的电刺激,然后在宰后 1 天和 14 天评估牛肉质量。每头牛的热重、臀部皮下脂肪厚度和动物在屠宰前 205 天的生长速度记录为牛肉质量的潜在影响因素。在宰后 1 天和 14 天,使用 Warner-Bratzler 峰值剪切力、压缩、pH 值、蒸煮损失和品尝小组可接受性,以及在宰后 1 天测量的水分和粗脂肪含量,评估背最长肌(LT)的质量。结果表明,在牧场上育肥的阉牛生长最慢,相同胴体重量下的皮下脂肪最少。在牧场上育肥的阉牛的 LT 平均肌节长度也最短,这表明这些肌肉可能受到冷应激的影响,但饮食对峰值剪切力没有影响。在牧场上育肥的阉牛的 LT 具有最高的平均压缩值,这可能是由于生长缓慢或运动增加导致胶原蛋白交联增加。老化显著降低了 LT 的峰值剪切力和压缩值,增加了蒸煮损失。品尝小组将经过老化处理的、草饲育肥的牛肉评为最嫩和质量最好的;然而,本研究中的品尝小组可能更喜欢草饲育肥的 LT,因为它比谷物育肥的阉牛胴体的 LT 明显更多汁。这些结果表明,胴体成分和加工条件的相互作用对 LT 的韧性和感官接受度的影响大于育肥饲料。对在牧场上育肥的阉牛的 LT 进行老化处理,改善了其颜色,从而可能提高其消费者的接受度。