Henneman P L, Marcus C S, Butler J A, Hall T A, Koci T M, Worthen N, Wilson S E
Department of Emergency Medicine, Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, Torrance 90509.
Am J Emerg Med. 1990 Sep;8(5):373-8. doi: 10.1016/0735-6757(90)90229-s.
The authors evaluated the use of technetium-99m albumin colloid white blood cell (TAC-WBC) scan in women with possible appendicitis. One hundred and nine women underwent 110 TAC-WBC scans. One woman had a second scan on a separate admission and was considered two individual patients in the analysis. Twenty-six women had appendicitis, 10 of whom had a perforated appendix at surgery. The TAC-WBC scan was indeterminate (abnormal but nondiagnostic for appendicitis) in 52 women (47%), nine of whom had appendicitis. Fifty-eight scans were read as positive or negative for appendiceal pathology. There were 16 true positives, 5 false positives, 36 true negatives, and 1 false negative. The predictive value of a positive scan was 76%, and the predictive value of a negative scan was 97%. The TAC-WBC scan was positive in 62% of patients with appendicitis and negative in 43% of the patients without appendicitis resulting in an overall accuracy of 47% in the 109 women. The main value of TAC-WBC scan in women with possible appendicitis is its high negative predictive value and the main problem with the TAC-WBC scan is its high indeterminate rate.
作者评估了锝-99m白蛋白胶体白细胞(TAC-WBC)扫描在疑似阑尾炎女性患者中的应用。109名女性接受了110次TAC-WBC扫描。其中一名女性在另一次住院时进行了第二次扫描,在分析中被视为两名独立患者。26名女性患有阑尾炎,其中10名在手术时阑尾穿孔。TAC-WBC扫描结果不确定(异常但不能诊断阑尾炎)的女性有52名(47%),其中9名患有阑尾炎。58次扫描对阑尾病变的结果为阳性或阴性。真阳性16例,假阳性5例,真阴性36例,假阴性1例。扫描阳性的预测值为76%,扫描阴性的预测值为97%。阑尾炎患者中62%的TAC-WBC扫描为阳性,无阑尾炎患者中43%的扫描为阴性,109名女性的总体准确率为47%。TAC-WBC扫描在疑似阑尾炎女性患者中的主要价值在于其高阴性预测值,而TAC-WBC扫描的主要问题在于其高不确定率。