Arnesi Nora, Hachuel Leticia
Instituto de Investigaciones Teóricas y Aplicadas, Escuela de Estadística, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Argentina.
Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2011 Sep;30(3):225-30. doi: 10.1590/s1020-49892011000900006.
Assess use of the intrinsic estimator (IE) technique in epidemiology.
The IE approach was applied to the analysis of breast cancer data in Argentina in order to observe the trends associated with "age, period, and cohort" (APC). This method involves the use of a principal components regression to obtain a single set of estimated trends. The results were compared to the findings obtained with the conventional method, which consists of adjusting a generalized linear model that includes the traditional constraints of the statistical model as well as an additional constraint (CGLM).
Both methods yielded compatible results in the trends associated with APC. However, they differed in the confidence intervals, with IE yielding greater efficiency. The curve associated with age showed the expected pattern of change across the life course: the greater the age, the greater the risk. With regard to cohorts, a decrease in the effects associated with the most recent cohorts was evident, whereas there was very little variation in the estimated effects for the period.
A comparison of the results obtained with the IE method and the CGLM method revealed the reach of the generic solution provided by the IE to the problem of estimates in an APC model. The IE method is based on conversion of the data observed using a weighting matrix that is simple to apply and provides estimates with desirable statistical properties.
评估内在估计器(IE)技术在流行病学中的应用。
将IE方法应用于阿根廷乳腺癌数据的分析,以观察与“年龄、时期和队列”(APC)相关的趋势。该方法涉及使用主成分回归来获得一组单一的估计趋势。将结果与通过传统方法获得的结果进行比较,传统方法包括调整一个广义线性模型,该模型包含统计模型的传统约束以及一个附加约束(CGLM)。
两种方法在与APC相关的趋势方面产生了兼容的结果。然而,它们在置信区间方面存在差异,IE方法具有更高的效率。与年龄相关的曲线显示了生命历程中预期的变化模式:年龄越大,风险越高。关于队列,与最近队列相关的效应明显下降,而时期的估计效应变化很小。
对IE方法和CGLM方法获得的结果进行比较,揭示了IE为APC模型中的估计问题提供的通用解决方案的适用范围。IE方法基于使用加权矩阵对观察到的数据进行转换,该加权矩阵易于应用,并提供具有理想统计特性的估计。