Bakhai A, Goodman F, Juchniewichz H, Martin A, Porter G, White C, Williams L, Hopkins A
Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Medical College of St Bartholomew's Hospital, London.
BMJ. 1990 Sep 15;301(6751):529-31. doi: 10.1136/bmj.301.6751.529.
To ascertain ease or difficulty of contacting duty junior doctors responsible for acute medical admissions by telephone.
Telephone survey of hospitals in six health regions in England and Wales.
70 Randomly selected hospitals, 15 of which were excluded because of non-acceptance of acute medical admissions.
71 Duty doctors (duty house physicians, senior house officers, or registrars responsible for acute medical admissions) in 48 hospitals; seven duty doctors in seven hospitals were excluded (four declined to participate and three required a written explanation of the survey). 67 Doctors gave full information to all questions.
Time taken for hospital switchboards and duty doctors to reply to telephone call, diagnoses of patients recently admitted, and on call rotas and hours of sleep of duty doctors.
Hospital switchboards responded within 30 seconds in 87 (74%) calls, and in 76 calls (64%) the duty doctor requested was contacted within a further two minutes. Chest pain, possibly due to myocardial infarction, was the most common reason for acute medical admissions. Nearly half (48%) of the duty doctors in larger hospitals reported having 4-5 hours sleep or less on their nights on call. Most (30) were on a one in three rota; two were on a one in two rota.
Despite impressions to the contrary contacting the duty medical team by telephone seemed fairly easy. Although most junior doctors were on a rota of one in three or better, insufficient recognition may be given to their deprivation of sleep during nights on duty.
确定通过电话联系负责急性内科住院患者的值班初级医生的难易程度。
对英格兰和威尔士六个卫生区域的医院进行电话调查。
随机选择70家医院,其中15家因不接收急性内科住院患者而被排除。
48家医院的71名值班医生(值班内科住院医师、高级住院医师或负责急性内科住院患者的住院医生);7家医院的7名值班医生被排除(4人拒绝参与,3人要求对调查进行书面解释)。67名医生对所有问题都提供了完整信息。
医院总机和值班医生回复电话的时间、近期入院患者的诊断、值班医生的值班轮班表和睡眠时间。
在87次(74%)呼叫中,医院总机在30秒内做出回应,在另外76次(64%)呼叫中,在接下来的两分钟内联系到了被要求的值班医生。胸痛,可能由于心肌梗死,是急性内科住院最常见的原因。大型医院近一半(48%)的值班医生报告称,他们值班当晚的睡眠时间为4至5小时或更少。大多数(30人)实行三人一轮值;两人实行两人一轮值。
尽管有相反的印象,但通过电话联系值班医疗团队似乎相当容易。虽然大多数初级医生实行三人一轮值或更好的轮值安排,但他们在值班当晚睡眠不足的情况可能没有得到充分认识。