School of Psychology, Bangor University, Bangor, Gwynedd, Wales, UK.
J Exp Anal Behav. 2011 Nov;96(3):291-315. doi: 10.1901/jeab.2011.96-291.
A series of three experiments explored the relationship between 3-year-old children's ability to name target body parts and their untrained matching of target hand-to-body touches. Nine participants, 3 per experiment, were presented with repeated generalized imitation tests in a multiple-baseline procedure, interspersed with step-by-step training that enabled them to (i) tact the target locations on their own and the experimenter's bodies or (ii) respond accurately as listeners to the experimenter's tacts of the target locations. Prompts for on-task naming of target body parts were also provided later in the procedure. In Experiment 1, only tact training followed by listener probes were conducted; in Experiment 2, tacting was trained first and listener behavior second, whereas in Experiment 3 listener training preceded tact training. Both tact and listener training resulted in emergence of naming together with significant and large improvements in the children's matching performances; this was true for each child and across most target gestures. The present series of experiments provides evidence that naming--the most basic form of self-instructional behavior--may be one means of establishing untrained matching as measured in generalized imitation tests. This demonstration has a bearing on our interpretation of imitation reported in the behavior analytic, cognitive developmental, and comparative literature.
一系列的三个实验探索了 3 岁儿童命名目标身体部位的能力与他们未经训练的目标手到身体接触匹配之间的关系。九名参与者,每个实验 3 名,在多个基线程序中接受了重复的广义模仿测试,穿插着逐步培训,使他们能够 (i) 自己和实验者的身体上的目标位置上进行触觉,或 (ii) 作为听众准确地对实验者的目标位置进行触觉做出反应。在程序的后期还提供了对目标身体部位进行任务相关命名的提示。在实验 1 中,只进行了触觉训练和听众探测;在实验 2 中,首先进行了触觉训练,其次是听众行为,而在实验 3 中,听众训练先于触觉训练。触觉和听众训练都导致了命名的出现,同时儿童的匹配表现也有显著和大幅度的提高;这对每个孩子和大多数目标手势都是如此。本系列实验提供了证据表明,命名——最基本的自我指导行为形式——可能是在广义模仿测试中建立未经训练的匹配的一种手段。这一演示对我们在行为分析、认知发展和比较文献中报告的模仿的解释产生了影响。