Ma Qi-shan, Zou Yu-hua, Zhang Shun-xiang, Liang Sen, Xiao He-wei, Xie Xu, Mei Shu-jiang, Jia Wei-dong, Zhang Yu-feng, Cui Fu-qiang, Wang Fu-zhen, Liang Xiao-feng
College of Public Health, Guangdong Pharmaceutical University, Guangzhou 510305, China; Shenzhen Center for Disease Control and Prevention.
Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi. 2011 Aug;32(8):764-7.
To estimate the intangible cost and associated factors on patients with hepatitis B-related diseases, so as to explore the differences of the three elicitation techniques on the 'willingness to pay approach' (WTP).
Face-to-Face interviews were conducted to collect health economics-related information by trained investigators, using a structured questionnaire. WTP was employed to estimate the intangible cost while an open-ended question format, together with iterative bidding game and payment card were respectively used to elicit WTP for the hypothetical cure of hepatitis B-related diseases. A Multiple linear stepwise regression model was determined to identify those factors potentially affecting the intangible cost.
A total of 564 subjects from 641 patients with hepatitis B-related diseases were identified for the inclusion of this study. The average annual intangible cost of patient with hepatitis B-related diseases was 54 320.4 Yuan (Ren Minbi). The intangible cost accounted for 53.0% of the total cost, which was much more than the proportions of the direct and indirect costs (38.5% and 8.5%, respectively). Among annual personal and the household income of the patient, proportions of intangible cost were 262.6% and 67.6% respectively, suggesting that the patients were under huge spiritual and psychological pressure. Response rate of the approach, combined open-ended questions with iterative bidding game, was the highest (76.6%) among the three elicitation formats. Considered the characteristics of data being gathered, the approach seemed to be more reasonable. Further studies were needed to examine the results yielded from other WTP elicitation formats. We also noticed that the progression of disease was associated with the increase of direct and indirect costs, but not with the intangible cost. Data from the multiple linear stepwise regression analysis indicated that the types of hospital and commercial medical insurance were significantly different in explaining the variation of the intangible cost.
Measures should be taken to reduce the intangible cost of hepatitis B-related diseases. The approach regarding the combination of open-ended questions with iterative bidding game should be recommended when carrying our further WTP studies of this kind.
评估乙型肝炎相关疾病患者的无形费用及相关因素,以探讨三种诱导技术在“支付意愿法”(WTP)上的差异。
由经过培训的调查员采用结构化问卷进行面对面访谈,收集与卫生经济学相关的信息。采用支付意愿法估算无形费用,同时分别使用开放式问题格式、迭代投标博弈和支付卡来诱导受访者对假设治愈乙型肝炎相关疾病的支付意愿。采用多元线性逐步回归模型确定那些可能影响无形费用的因素。
从641例乙型肝炎相关疾病患者中确定了564名受试者纳入本研究。乙型肝炎相关疾病患者的年均无形费用为54320.4元(人民币)。无形费用占总成本的53.0%,远高于直接成本和间接成本的比例(分别为38.5%和8.5%)。在患者的年度个人收入和家庭收入中,无形费用的比例分别为262.6%和67.6%,表明患者承受着巨大的精神和心理压力。在三种诱导形式中,将开放式问题与迭代投标博弈相结合的方法的应答率最高(76.6%)。考虑到所收集数据的特点,该方法似乎更合理。需要进一步研究以检验其他支付意愿诱导形式产生的结果。我们还注意到疾病进展与直接和间接成本的增加相关,但与无形费用无关。多元线性逐步回归分析的数据表明,医院类型和商业医疗保险在解释无形费用的变化方面存在显著差异。
应采取措施降低乙型肝炎相关疾病的无形费用。在进行此类进一步的支付意愿研究时,建议采用将开放式问题与迭代投标博弈相结合的方法。