D'Alessandro A, Simon D, Coignet M C, Cenée S, Giorgino R, Eschwege E
Clinica Medica III, Cattedra di Endocrinologia e Medicina costituzionale, Bari, Italie.
Diabete Metab. 1990 May-Jun;16(3):213-9.
A population of 495 volunteer subjects who applied to the screening diabetes Centre of Hôtel-Dieu hospital in Paris has been studied and divided into two samples. In the first 300 subjects sample the sensitivity and the specificity of different fasting blood glucose threshold values, of different glycosylated hemoglobin threshold levels and of various combinations of the above mentioned parameter have been evaluated as a test for diabetes diagnosis defined by a 2-hr OGTT value greater than or equal to 200 mg/dl. The predictive values for both positive and negative diagnosis were also evaluated. The combination of a fasting blood glucose greater than or equal to 120 mg/dl with a glycosylated hemoglobin greater than 5.8% was found to be the best association with a good relative specificity (97.9%), a fair sensitivity (64.7%) and a fair predictive value for a positive diagnosis (64.7%). A second sample includes 195 subjects. These were classified according to either the above criterion or either the 2-hr OGTT value greater than or equal to 200 mg/dl. A great majority of subjects (95.4%) was classified in concordance by the two methods. The characteristics of the subjects that were identically classified as diabetic subjects (n = 5) were compared to those of differently classified subjects (n = 9). Longitudinal surveys are needed in order to assess the validity of HbA1c measurement as a tool for diabetes screening by reference to unquestionable criteria of the disease.
对495名申请巴黎迪厄医院糖尿病筛查中心的志愿者进行了研究,并将其分为两个样本。在第一个包含300名受试者的样本中,评估了不同空腹血糖阈值、不同糖化血红蛋白阈值水平以及上述参数的各种组合作为糖尿病诊断测试的敏感性和特异性,糖尿病诊断由2小时口服葡萄糖耐量试验(OGTT)值大于或等于200mg/dl定义。还评估了阳性和阴性诊断的预测值。发现空腹血糖大于或等于120mg/dl与糖化血红蛋白大于5.8%的组合具有良好的相对特异性(97.9%)、尚可的敏感性(64.7%)和阳性诊断的尚可预测值(64.7%),是最佳组合。第二个样本包括195名受试者。这些受试者根据上述标准或2小时OGTT值大于或等于200mg/dl进行分类。绝大多数受试者(95.4%)通过两种方法分类一致。将被同样分类为糖尿病患者的受试者(n = 5)的特征与分类不同的受试者(n = 9)的特征进行了比较。需要进行纵向调查,以便参照明确的疾病标准评估糖化血红蛋白测量作为糖尿病筛查工具的有效性。