Centre for Physical Activity Across the Lifespan, School of Exercise Science, Australian Catholic University, Melbourne, Australia.
J Sports Sci. 2012;30(2):191-9. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2011.633927. Epub 2011 Dec 6.
We determined the inter-day variability in elite-standard women's artistic gymnastics competition scores. National (50 gymnasts for up to three days) and Olympic (24 gymnasts for up to five days) competition scores published in the public domain ('Giant poster pull-out', 2010 ; Gymnastics Australia, 2008 ) were evaluated using three statistical measures. Analyses of the inter-day differences in the mean scores as a percentage (MDiff%), coefficient of variation percentages for the mean score across both days (CV%), and Pearson correlation coefficients for the inter-day score (r) were interpreted using thresholds from trivial to large. National-class gymnasts' two-day performance variation was trivial for vault, small for floor and beam, and moderate for bars. When senior gymnasts competed for a third day the performance variation increased to moderate for vault. Across five days of Olympic competition there were trivial (e.g. CV%: vault = 0.8) to small (e.g. CV%: bars = 2.0) variations in performances between days on all apparatus. Olympians' performance score consistency is superior to senior, national-class competitors. The performance score consistency required for gymnasts who aspire to participate at the Olympics as a top-24 competitor is better than 3%.
我们确定了精英标准女子艺术体操比赛评分的日内变异性。使用三种统计措施评估了在公共领域公布的国家(50 名体操运动员,最多三天)和奥运会(24 名体操运动员,最多五天)比赛评分(“巨型海报拉出来”,2010 年;澳大利亚体操,2008 年)。分析了平均分数的日内差异百分比(MDiff%)、两天内平均分数的变异系数百分比(CV%)以及日内得分的皮尔逊相关系数(r),使用从微不足道到较大的阈值进行解释。对于跳马,国家级别体操运动员两天的表现变化微不足道,地板和横梁小,棒中等。当高级体操运动员第三天比赛时,跳马的表现变化增加到中等。在五天的奥运会比赛中,所有器械上的两天之间的表现差异都微不足道(例如 CV%:跳马=0.8)到小(例如 CV%:棒=2.0)。希望作为前 24 名参赛者参加奥运会的运动员的表现得分一致性优于高级、国家级竞争对手。有资格参加奥运会的体操运动员的表现得分一致性要求优于 3%。