WHO Collaborating Center for Water Supply and Waste Disposal, Environmental Engineering and Management, Asian Institute of Technology, P.O. Box 4, Klong Luang, Pathumthani 12120, Thailand.
Ecohealth. 2011 Sep;8(3):349-64. doi: 10.1007/s10393-011-0724-8. Epub 2011 Dec 7.
Assessment of microbial hazards associated with certain environmental matrices, livelihood strategies, and food handling practices are constrained by time-consuming conventional microbiological techniques that lead to health risk assessments of narrow geographic or time scope, often targeting very few pathogens. Health risk assessment based on one or few indicator organisms underestimates true disease burden due a number of coexisting causative pathogens. Here, we employed molecular techniques in a survey of Cryptosporidium parvum, Giardia lamblia, Campylobacter jejuni, Escherichia coli O157:H7, Listeria monocytogenes, Salmonella spp., Shigella spp., Vibrio cholera, and Rotavirus A densities in canal water with respect to seasonality and spatial distribution of point-nonpoint pollution sources. Three irrigational canals stretching across nearly a 150-km(2) periurban landscape, traditionally used for agricultural irrigation but function as vital part of municipal wastewater stabilization in recent years, were investigated. Compiled stochastic data (pathogen concentration, susceptible populations) and literature-obtained deterministic data (pathogen dose-response model parameter values) were used in estimating waterborne gastroenteritis burden. Exposure scenarios include swimming or fishing, consuming canal water-irrigated vegetables, and ingesting or inhaling water aerosols while working in canal water-irrigated fields. Estimated annual gastroenteritis burden due individual pathogens among the sampling points was -10.6log(10) to -2.2log(10) DALYs. Aggregated annual gastroenteritis burden due all the target pathogens per sampling point was -3.1log(10) to -1.9log(10) DALYs, far exceeding WHO acceptable limit of -6.0log(10) DALYs. The present approach will facilitate the comprehensive collection of surface water microbiological baseline data and setting of benchmarks for interventions aimed at reducing microbial hazards in similar landscapes worldwide.
评估与某些环境基质、生计策略和食品处理方法相关的微生物危害受到耗时的传统微生物学技术的限制,这些技术导致健康风险评估的地理或时间范围狭窄,通常针对极少数病原体。基于一种或几种指示生物的健康风险评估会低估由于存在许多共存病原体而导致的真正疾病负担。在这里,我们采用分子技术调查了运河水中微小隐孢子虫、兰伯氏贾第鞭毛虫、空肠弯曲菌、大肠杆菌 O157:H7、李斯特菌、沙门氏菌、志贺氏菌、霍乱弧菌和轮状病毒 A 的密度,考虑到季节性和点源-非点源污染的空间分布。我们调查了三条横跨近 150 平方公里城市周边景观的灌溉运河,这些运河传统上用于农业灌溉,但近年来已成为城市废水稳定化的重要组成部分。编译了随机数据(病原体浓度、易感人群)和文献获得的确定性数据(病原体剂量反应模型参数值)用于估计水传播胃肠炎负担。暴露情景包括游泳或钓鱼、食用用运河水灌溉的蔬菜以及在运河水灌溉的田地工作时摄入或吸入水气溶胶。在采样点中,由于个别病原体引起的每年胃肠炎负担估计为 -10.6log(10) 至 -2.2log(10) DALY。所有目标病原体在每个采样点的综合年胃肠炎负担为 -3.1log(10) 至 -1.9log(10) DALY,远远超过世卫组织可接受的 -6.0log(10) DALY 限值。这种方法将有助于全面收集地表水微生物学基线数据,并为旨在减少全球类似景观中微生物危害的干预措施设定基准。