Manjunath Prasad K S, Mahmood Sajeda, Gregson Barbara A, Mitchell Patrick
Department of Neurosurgery, James Cook University Hospital, Middlesbrough, UK.
Br J Neurosurg. 2012 Apr;26(2):195-8. doi: 10.3109/02688697.2011.633643. Epub 2011 Dec 9.
With a constant debate on working hours and improved patient outcomes, time studies are crucial to obtain and analyse timelines and work components. This includes time spent on communication. The aim of this study was to assess the magnitude and patterns of telephone call episodes in the work schedule of neurosurgery trainees.
Logs of handheld telephone sets assigned to neurosurgery specialty trainees in a British regional neurosurgical centre were obtained from the hospital switchboard for a 6-month period. This formed the primary data. Ringtime was added to the talktime for outgoing calls. Monday to Friday, 8 am-5 pm was considered as regular hours and the rest as other hours. The outcome measures used were number and duration of telephone episodes (individual and collective) and the timing of these episodes.
During the study period of 6 months, there were 12071 incoming calls and 10712 outgoing calls (total calls-22783). The maximum number of incoming calls/ day/ trainee was in the range of 39-78 while the range for outgoing calls was 36-102. On an average, the on-call trainee made and received 33 and 36 calls respectively in a 24-hour period (mean call duration was 1.7 minutes) which meant that a telephone call intruded into the schedule almost once every 21 minutes. Typically, the on-call trainee spent 138 minutes on the telephone (69 calls) in 24 hours, while on an off-call day it was significantly less at 25 minutes (18 calls). Of the calls, 67% happened out of regular hours.
Time spent on the telephone is a significant work component and would have a bearing on timelines.
鉴于关于工作时长与改善患者治疗效果的争论持续不断,时间研究对于获取和分析时间线及工作构成要素至关重要。这其中包括用于沟通的时间。本研究的目的是评估神经外科实习医生工作日程中电话通话事件的数量及模式。
从一家英国地区神经外科中心的医院总机获取分配给神经外科专业实习医生的手持电话机的通话记录,为期6个月。这构成了主要数据。呼出电话的通话时长加上振铃时长。周一至周五上午8点至下午5点被视为正常工作时间,其余时间为其他时间。所采用的结果指标为电话通话事件(个人和集体)的数量及时长,以及这些事件的时间安排。
在6个月的研究期间,有12071次来电和10712次呼出电话(总通话次数为22783次)。每位实习医生每天来电的最大数量在39 - 78次之间,呼出电话的范围是36 - 102次。平均而言,值班实习医生在24小时内分别打出和接听33次和36次电话(平均通话时长为1.7分钟),这意味着几乎每21分钟就有一次电话打断日程安排。通常,值班实习医生在24小时内花138分钟打电话(69次通话),而在非值班日则显著减少,为25分钟(18次通话)。在这些通话中,67%发生在正常工作时间之外。
花在电话上的时间是一项重要的工作构成要素,会对时间线产生影响。