Gong Yu-Bao, Li Qing-Song, Yang Chen, Li Shu-Qiang, Liu Jian-Guo, Qi Xin
Department of Bone and Joint, First Hospital of Jilin University, Changchun 130021, China.
Chin J Traumatol. 2011;14(6):376-8.
Hoffa fracture associated with ipsilateral femoral shaft fracture is very rare. Three cases of this rare type of injury were retrospectively reviewed. The sites of femoral shaft fractures and Hoffa fractures were documented. All femoral shaft fractures were managed with internal fixation. The rate of misdiagnosis for the Hoffa fractures was documented. Functions of the affected knees were evaluated according to the modified Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) scores at two years follow-up. Femoral fractures were either transverse or composite in all three cases. Ipsilateral Hoffa fractures occurred at medial condyle in two cases, and lateral condyle in one case. Only one Hoffa fracture was identified preoperatively. All the femoral shaft fractures healed uneventfully. In the patient whose Hoffa fracture was correctly diagnosed, the modified HSS score was 94. In another patient, whose Hoffa fracture was treated by a second operation, the modified HSS score was 93. And in the third case, who refused additional operation for the Hoffa fracture, the modified HSS score was only 70. Conclusively femoral shaft fracture can be associated with ipsilateral Hoffa fracture, especially in motorcycle accident. This type of injury is very rare and misdiagnosis is common.
与同侧股骨干骨折相关的Hoffa骨折非常罕见。回顾性分析了3例这种罕见的损伤病例。记录了股骨干骨折和Hoffa骨折的部位。所有股骨干骨折均采用内固定治疗。记录了Hoffa骨折的误诊率。在两年随访时,根据改良的特种外科医院(HSS)评分评估患膝功能。3例患者的股骨干骨折均为横行或复合骨折。同侧Hoffa骨折2例发生在内侧髁,1例发生在外侧髁。术前仅确诊1例Hoffa骨折。所有股骨干骨折均顺利愈合。Hoffa骨折被正确诊断的患者,改良HSS评分为94分。另一例Hoffa骨折经二次手术治疗的患者,改良HSS评分为93分。第三例患者拒绝接受Hoffa骨折的额外手术,改良HSS评分仅为70分。结论是股骨干骨折可与同侧Hoffa骨折相关,尤其是在摩托车事故中。这种损伤非常罕见,误诊很常见。