Department of Podiatry, Harrogate District Hospital, Harrogate, UK.
Forensic Sci Int. 2012 Jun 10;219(1-3):283.e1-5. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2011.11.018. Epub 2011 Dec 9.
The ability to estimate accurately from known parameters is a fundamental aspect of science and is evident as an emerging approach in the area of footprints and stature estimation within the field of forensic identification. There are numerous foot dimensions that have been measured in the literature to predict stature with varying degrees of confidence but few studies have tried to link the strength of estimation to anatomical landmarks. Such an approach is utilised in this study which estimates stature from the right footprints of sixty one adult male and female UK participants. Static and dynamic footprints were taken from each volunteer using the 'inkless paper system'. The prints were digitised and twelve length, width and angle measurements were chosen for the analysis. The highest correlations with stature were shown to be the heel to fourth toe print for the static group of footprints (r=0.786, p<0.01), and the heel to fifth toe print in the dynamic footprints (r=0.858, p<0.01). Collinearity statistics suggest the heel to fifth toe print length measurement is independent and not influenced by any other variables in the estimation of stature for the dynamic prints. Linear regression equations for this measurement presented the smallest standard error of estimate (SEE) and highest shared variance (R(2)) of all included variables (SEE 4.16, R(2) 0.74). Our study discusses a potential anatomical explanation as to why the lateral border of the foot and hence the impression it makes upon a hard surface, is a more stable indicator in the estimation of stature. The investigation recommends the use of Calc_A4 and Calc_A5 length measurements when estimating stature from footprint impressions.
从已知参数准确估计的能力是科学的一个基本方面,在法医鉴定领域的足迹和身高估计领域,这是一种新兴的方法。文献中已经测量了许多足尺寸,以不同程度的置信度预测身高,但很少有研究试图将估计的强度与解剖学标志联系起来。本研究采用这种方法,根据 61 名英国成年男性和女性参与者的右脚足迹估计身高。使用“无墨纸系统”从每个志愿者身上采集静态和动态足迹。对足迹进行数字化处理,并选择 12 个长度、宽度和角度测量值进行分析。静态足迹中,脚跟到第四趾的足迹与身高的相关性最高(r=0.786,p<0.01),动态足迹中,脚跟到第五趾的足迹相关性最高(r=0.858,p<0.01)。共线性统计表明,在动态足迹中,第五趾到脚跟的长度测量值是独立的,不受估计身高时其他变量的影响。该测量值的线性回归方程呈现出最小的估计标准误差(SEE)和最高的共享方差(R²),高于所有包含变量的 SEE(SEE 4.16,R² 0.74)。我们的研究讨论了一个潜在的解剖学解释,即为什么足部的外侧边界,以及它在坚硬表面上留下的印象,是估计身高的更稳定指标。该研究建议在从足迹印痕估计身高时使用 Calc_A4 和 Calc_A5 长度测量值。