Sleep Research Centre, Loughborough University, Loughborough, Leicestershire, LE11 3TU, UK.
Physiol Behav. 2012 Feb 28;105(4):1088-91. doi: 10.1016/j.physbeh.2011.11.025. Epub 2011 Dec 6.
The 'post-lunch' dip is a bi-circadian phenomenon, largely unrelated to lunch, and worsened by a disturbed prior night's sleep. Despite anecdotal claims of adverse effects of larger lunches on afternoon driving ability, there is little actual driving data to support this belief. Although there have been various (non-driving) laboratory studies assessing meal size and micronutrient effects on psychological performance tests, findings are mixed. Moreover, most have not utilised heightened afternoon sleepiness after a shortened night's sleep, and few tested beyond 20 min. Using a real car interactive simulator having full size screen projection, we compared the effects on a 2h monotonous afternoon drive, of two very similar, palatable lunches ('light': 305 cal vs 'heavy': 922 cal [having 3× fat and 2× carbohydrate contents]), given double blind in a repeated measures counterbalanced design, to 12 young male drivers whose prior night's sleep had been restricted to 5h. Sleepiness-related lane drifting ('incidents'), subjective sleepiness and EEG (4-11 Hz power - indicative of sleepiness) were logged throughout. The heavy lunch caused significant increases to both incidents and EEG power, and a trend for greater subjective sleepiness. All three indices showed a significant worsening of sleepiness over the drive under both lunch conditions. Whilst there were no significant condition×time interactions, there was no difference between lunches for at least the first 30 min of the drive when, thereafter, the differences appeared. Ours was a realistic driving study, utilising typical lunches, following an unexceptional level of prior sleep loss, and where a heavy lunch exacerbated inherent sleepiness, to further impair monotonous driving.
“午饭后”困倦是一种双昼夜节律现象,与午餐关系不大,而前一晚睡眠受到干扰会使其恶化。尽管有传言称午餐吃得过多会影响下午开车的能力,但实际上几乎没有驾驶数据支持这种说法。尽管有各种(非驾驶)实验室研究评估了餐量和微量营养素对心理表现测试的影响,但结果不一。此外,大多数研究没有利用夜间睡眠时间缩短后下午的嗜睡增加,并且很少进行超过 20 分钟的测试。使用具有全尺寸屏幕投影的真实汽车互动模拟器,我们比较了两种非常相似的美味午餐(“清淡”:305 卡路里与“丰盛”:922 卡路里[含有 3 倍脂肪和 2 倍碳水化合物])对 12 名年轻男性驾驶员的影响,这些驾驶员在前一晚的睡眠被限制在 5 小时内,在重复测量的平衡设计中进行了双盲实验。困倦相关的车道偏离(“事故”)、主观困倦和 EEG(4-11Hz 功率-表示困倦)在整个过程中进行记录。丰盛的午餐会导致事故和 EEG 功率明显增加,以及主观困倦程度的增加趋势。在两种午餐条件下,整个驾驶过程中这三个指标的困倦程度都明显恶化。尽管没有明显的条件×时间相互作用,但在至少前 30 分钟的驾驶中,两种午餐之间没有差异,此后差异出现。我们的研究是一项现实的驾驶研究,使用了典型的午餐,遵循了不例外的睡眠不足水平,而丰盛的午餐加剧了固有的困倦,进一步损害了单调的驾驶。