Department of Medical Oncology, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, 450 Brookline Ave, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 2012 Jan 10;30(2):158-63. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2011.36.9264. Epub 2011 Dec 12.
As the number of breast cancer survivors increases, a durable model of comprehensive survivor care is needed, incorporating providers and/or visit types both within and outside of oncology. The objective of this study was to explore survivors' comfort with different clinician types or with a telephone/Internet-based virtual visit as components of survivorship care.
Breast cancer survivors participating in a general survivorship survey completed an additional breast cancer-specific questionnaire evaluating the self-perceived impact of follow-up visits to various clinician types, or follow-up by a virtual visit, on survival, worrying, and stress related to cancer.
A total of 218 breast cancer survivors completed the questionnaire. Most favored medical oncologist follow-up visits over those with primary care physicians (PCPs) or nurse practitioners (NPs) in terms of reduced worrying about cancer (odds ratio [OR], 2.21; P < .001), reduced stress around the visit (OR, 1.40; P = .002), and improved effect on cancer survival (OR, 2.38; P < .001). However, the majority also displayed substantial comfort with both PCPs and NPs in the same domains. Patients rated a virtual visit as having a less favorable impact on cancer survival and cancer-related worrying compared with in-person visits with clinicians.
Breast cancer survivors are comfortable with both PCPs and NPs providing follow-up care, although they indicate a preference for medical oncologists. Given patients' negative impressions of a virtual visit, increased familiarity with and research investigating this emerging concept are needed. The NP-led survivorship clinic model, with increased guidance for PCPs, offers a promising route for improving quality of and satisfaction with survivor care.
随着乳腺癌幸存者人数的增加,需要建立一种持久的综合幸存者护理模式,将肿瘤学内外的提供者和/或就诊类型纳入其中。本研究的目的是探讨幸存者对不同临床医生类型或电话/互联网虚拟就诊作为生存护理的一部分的舒适度。
参与一般生存调查的乳腺癌幸存者完成了一项额外的乳腺癌特定问卷,评估了各种临床医生类型的随访就诊或通过虚拟就诊对生存、担忧和与癌症相关的压力的自我感知影响。
共有 218 名乳腺癌幸存者完成了问卷。在减少对癌症的担忧(优势比 [OR],2.21;P <.001)、减少就诊时的压力(OR,1.40;P =.002)和改善癌症生存效果(OR,2.38;P <.001)方面,大多数患者更倾向于选择肿瘤医生的随访就诊,而不是选择初级保健医生(PCP)或护士执业医师(NP)。然而,大多数患者在相同的领域也对 PCP 和 NP 都有很大的舒适度。患者认为虚拟就诊对癌症生存和癌症相关的担忧的影响不如与临床医生的面对面就诊。
乳腺癌幸存者对 PCP 和 NP 提供的随访护理都感到舒适,尽管他们表示更喜欢肿瘤医生。鉴于患者对虚拟就诊的负面印象,需要增加对这一新兴概念的熟悉程度和研究。以 NP 为主导的生存诊所模式,为 PCP 提供更多的指导,为改善生存护理的质量和满意度提供了一个有前途的途径。