First collaborative experience with thulium laser ablation of localized upper urinary tract urothelial tumors using retrograde intra-renal surgery.

PURPOSE

Thulium laser ablation (TLA) outcomes with blinded performance evaluation after retrograde intra-renal surgical (RIRS) treatment of upper urinary tract transitional cell carcinomas (UUT-TCC).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A UUT-TCC patient cohort undergoing RIRS-TLA by an international endoscopic surgical collaboration in a European center (April 2005-July 2009), underwent outcomes evaluation. All 4 surgeons were blinded and independently scored both TLA and Holmium:YAG laser ablation performance aspects annually using a Likert scoring system (0-10).

RESULTS

All patients (n = 59, median age 66 years, 9 with solitary kidney) had complete UUT inspection. Presenting lesion(s) were intra-renal (n = 30, 51%), ureteral (n = 13, 22%), and combined (n = 16, 27%). Single-stage TLA sufficed in 81.4% (tumors < 1.5 cm). Significant recurrence free survival differences occurred according to primary tumor size >/< 1.5 cm and multi-focality, but location made no difference. Median Likert scores were i) fiber-tip stability --5.5/8.75, p = 0.016; ii) reduced bleeding--5/8.5, p = 0.004; iii)fiber-tip precision--5.5/8.5, p = 0.003; iv) mucosal perforation reduction--3.5/7.5, p = 0.001; v) ablation efficiency tumors < 1.5 cm--6/9, p = 0.017; tumors > 1.5 cm--6.75/6.75, p = 1, and vi) overall efficiency--6/7.5, p = 0.09, for Holmium:YAG and TLA, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The Thulium laser delivered non-inferior recurrence free survival to RIRS-UUT-TCC Holmium:YAG laser ablation, but better median parameter performance scores in fiber-tip stability, precision, reduced bleeding and mucosal perforation reduction in expert ratings. Despite improved photothermal coagulation, and endo-visualization for tumors < 1.5 cm, both ablation and overall efficiency remained challenging for larger tumors with both existing laser technologies.