Matsumoto Kenji, Hotori Chika, Tanaka Saori, Arima Kazuyo, Komukai Jun, Danno Katsura, Yoshida Hideki, Hirota Satoshi, Koda Shinichi, Terakawa Kazuhiko, Shimouchi Akira
Osaka City Public Health Office, Osaka, Japan.
Kekkaku. 2011 Oct;86(10):815-20.
Factors responsible for the premature self-discharge of homeless tuberculosis (TB) patients from the hospital and the association between the self-discharge and treatment interruption were assessed.
A total of 205 homeless patients with TBs who were newly registered between January, 2007 and June, 2008 were evaluated. The subjects were divided into two groups (those who were discharged themselves from the hospital prematurely ["case" group] and those who were not [control group]), and the difference between the groups regarding the factors possibly responsible for the self-discharge was evaluated.
i) Patient's characteristics: The subjects were all men; there were 45 in the "case" group and 160 in the control group. The proportion of subjects aged under 60 years was significantly higher in the "case" group (84.4%) than in the control group (52.5%). The proportion of subjects who consumed 360 mL or more of sake a day was significantly higher in the "case" group (64.4%) than in the control group (38.8%). ii) Questionnaire survey on admission: All of the patients were hospitalized for treatment of TB. In the interview on admission, more "case" group patients reported "I do not know much about TB" or "I am dissatisfied with my hospitalization", as shown by multiple logistic regression analysis. A review of troubles with inmates or healthcare workers over alcohol drinking or smoking showed that the proportion of subjects who had such troubles was significantly higher in the "case" group (55.6%) than in the control group (5.0%). iii) The association between the treatment outcomes and the self-discharge: The proportion of subjects with treatment outcomes of "cured" or "treatment completed" was significantly lower in the "case" group (46.7%) than in the control group (78.8%). The proportion of subjects with a treatment outcome of "defaulted" was significantly higher in the "case" group (42.2%) than in the control group (3.8%).
The patients who were aged under 60 years or who consumed 360 mL or more of sake a day were shown to be significantly more likely to discharge themselves prematurely, which warrants a more careful handling of such problems. The poor understanding of disease necessitates more adequate explanation of TB, or education, considering each patient's level of understanding. In addition, the patients' dissatisfaction with their hospital stay, as seen in the case group, should be more carefully addressed in order to avoid the higher rate of trouble.
评估导致无家可归的结核病患者过早自行出院的因素以及自行出院与治疗中断之间的关联。
对2007年1月至2008年6月期间新登记的205例无家可归的结核病患者进行了评估。将受试者分为两组(过早自行出院的患者["病例"组]和未过早自行出院的患者[对照组]),并评估两组之间可能导致自行出院的因素差异。
i)患者特征:受试者均为男性;“病例”组有45例,对照组有160例。“病例”组中60岁以下受试者的比例(84.4%)显著高于对照组(52.5%)。“病例”组中每天饮用360毫升或更多清酒的受试者比例(64.4%)显著高于对照组(38.8%)。ii)入院问卷调查:所有患者均因结核病住院治疗。入院访谈中,多项逻辑回归分析显示,更多“病例”组患者表示“对结核病了解不多”或“对住院不满意”。对与同室患者或医护人员在饮酒或吸烟方面的纠纷进行回顾发现,“病例”组中存在此类纠纷的受试者比例(55.6%)显著高于对照组(5.0%)。iii)治疗结果与自行出院之间的关联:“病例”组中治疗结果为“治愈”或“完成治疗”的受试者比例(46.7%)显著低于对照组(78.8%)。“病例”组中治疗结果为“违约”的受试者比例(42.2%)显著高于对照组(3.8%)。
60岁以下或每天饮用360毫升或更多清酒的患者被证明更有可能过早自行出院,这需要更谨慎地处理此类问题。考虑到每个患者的理解水平,对疾病的了解不足需要对结核病进行更充分的解释或教育。此外,应更谨慎地处理病例组中患者对住院的不满,以避免更高的纠纷发生率。