Department of Cardiology and Angiology, University Hospital Münster, Münster, Germany.
Heart Rhythm. 2012 May;9(5):704-8. doi: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2011.12.024. Epub 2011 Dec 31.
Electrophysiologic characteristics, mapping strategies, and acute success rates of radiofrequency catheter ablation of atriofascicular accessory pathways are well described. However, data on long-term prognosis and predictors for freedom from arrhythmias are lacking.
To report our 20-year single-center experience on ablation of atriofascicular fibers.
Between 1992 and 2010, 34 patients with atriofascicular accessory pathways underwent catheter ablation at our institution because of symptomatic antidromic atrioventricular reentrant tachycardias. Radiofrequency procedures were retrospectively analyzed, and patients were followed for recurrences of tachyarrhythmias. Electrocardiograms (before and after ablation and at follow-up) were analyzed for each patient.
Successful catheter ablation of the atriofascicular fiber was achieved in 23 (68%) patients. Mechanical block during mapping occurred in 3 (9%) patients, and in 2 of them ablation was performed at the site of mechanical block. Mere modification of conduction properties of the pathway without complete block was achieved in 5 patients (15%). Fast pathway ablation was performed in 2 (6%) of the patients ablated in the early 1990s. During follow-up of 9.3 ± 5.5 years, 24 patients (71%) remained free of tachyarrhythmias, 7 reported significant improvement, and 3 (9%) had no change in symptoms after ablation. Long-term success was identical between patients from the first (1992-1999) and second (2000-2010) decade (12 of 17 [71%] vs 12 of 17 [71%]). It was 87% in those with complete block of the atriofascicular fiber while all patients with mechanical block during mapping reported recurrences. Fast pathway ablation was complicated by complete atrioventricular block in 1 patient, who required pacemaker implantation 18 years after ablation owing to loss of conduction properties of the atriofascicular fiber over the years. On analyzing patients with preexcitation before ablation (n = 16; 47%), we found that the PR interval after ablation was significantly longer only in those without recurrence (162 ± 21 ms vs 134 ± 21 ms; P = .042). None of the other analyzed electrocardiographic parameters, including PR, QRS duration, and preexcitation, had prognostic impact.
Acute success of complete ablation of atriofascicular pathways is associated with excellent long-term success (87%). Mere modification of conduction properties of atriofascicular fibers or ablation at the sites of mechanical block are less promising end points of ablation with high recurrence rates. Technical innovations during decades may not further improve long-term outcome in these patients.
已有大量研究详细描述了房室结旁路的电生理特征、标测策略和射频导管消融的急性成功率。然而,关于长期预后和预测无心律失常的因素的数据仍缺乏。
报告我们机构 20 年来应用导管消融房室结旁路的经验。
1992 年至 2010 年间,因顺向型房室折返性心动过速而出现症状的 34 例患者在我院接受了房室结旁路的导管消融治疗。回顾性分析了射频消融过程,并对患者进行了随访,以了解心律失常的复发情况。对每位患者的心电图(消融前后和随访时)进行了分析。
23 例(68%)患者成功地进行了房室结旁路的完全消融。3 例(9%)患者在标测过程中出现机械性阻滞,其中 2 例在机械性阻滞部位进行了消融。5 例(15%)患者仅出现旁路传导特性的改变而未完全阻滞。2 例(6%)在 20 世纪 90 年代早期接受消融的患者行快径消融。随访 9.3±5.5 年后,24 例(71%)患者无心动过速发作,7 例患者报告症状明显改善,3 例(9%)患者消融后症状无变化。第一(1992-1999 年)和第二(2000-2010 年)个十年组患者的长期成功率均相同(17 例患者中分别为 12 例[71%])。完全阻滞旁路的患者中 87%成功,而所有在标测过程中出现机械性阻滞的患者均出现复发。1 例患者行快径消融后出现完全性房室传导阻滞,由于房室结旁路的传导特性在消融后数年内逐渐丧失,18 年后需要植入起搏器。在分析消融前存在预激的 16 例患者(47%)时,我们发现只有无复发的患者的 PR 间期在消融后明显延长(162±21 ms 比 134±21 ms;P=0.042)。其他分析的心电图参数,包括 PR 间期、QRS 时限和预激,均无预后意义。
完全消融房室结旁路的急性成功率与良好的长期成功率(87%)相关。仅改变房室结旁路的传导特性或在机械性阻滞部位进行消融的患者,其复发率较高,预后较差。在过去的几十年中技术创新可能并不能进一步改善此类患者的长期预后。