Department of Crop and Soil Sciences, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA.
J Hazard Mater. 2012 Feb 29;205-206:144-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2011.12.049. Epub 2011 Dec 27.
Long-term application of lead arsenate in orchards has led to a significant accumulation of Pb and As in the topsoil. Reclamation of old orchards for agricultural purposes entails the exposure of humans to Pb and As, which can be reduced by adequate remediation actions. In this study, we assessed the remediation efficiency of compost addition, commonly used as a sustainable agricultural practice, in decreasing the human exposure Pb and As by direct ingestion. The remediation was evaluated based on Pb and As bioavailability, assessed by means of a selective non-exhaustive chemical extraction (modified Morgan extraction, MME), with a physiologically based extraction test (PBET) for the assessment of Pb and As bioavailability in ingested soils and with a novel in vivo bioaccumulation test with isopods (Porcellio scaber). All the tests showed that compost addition consistently reduced Pb, but increased As potential bioavailability. The bioaccumulation test with P. scaber was sensitive to changes in Pb and As bioavailability in test soils. However, the results indicate that the bioavailability of As could be under- or overestimated using solely chemical extraction tests. Indirect assessment of trace metal bioavailability with bioaccumulation in isopods can be used as complementary source of data to the existing in vitro chemical extraction test approach for the estimation of human exposure to trace elements in polluted and remediated soil. This is the first report on the use of As accumulation in P. scaber as a tool for the assessment of As bioavailability in contaminated orchard soil.
长期在果园中使用含铅砷的药剂会导致表土中铅和砷的大量积累。为了农业目的而开垦旧果园会使人类接触到铅和砷,而通过适当的修复措施可以减少这种接触。在本研究中,我们评估了添加堆肥作为一种可持续农业实践的修复效率,以减少人类通过直接摄入而接触到的铅和砷。修复效果是基于铅和砷的生物有效性来评估的,采用了选择性非萃取化学提取法(改良摩根提取法,MME)、基于生理学的提取试验(PBET)来评估摄入土壤中铅和砷的生物有效性,以及采用新型的活体生物累积试验(食土马陆 Porcellio scaber)。所有试验均表明,添加堆肥可有效降低铅的含量,但会增加砷的潜在生物有效性。食土马陆生物累积试验对试验土壤中铅和砷生物有效性的变化敏感。然而,结果表明,仅使用化学提取试验可能会低估或高估砷的生物有效性。利用食土马陆进行痕量金属生物有效性的间接评估,可以作为现有的体外化学提取试验方法的补充数据来源,用于评估受污染和修复土壤中微量元素对人类的暴露风险。这是首次报道利用食土马陆对砷的积累来评估污染果园土壤中砷的生物有效性。