Li Qi, Ma Kai-Jun, Zhang Xiao-Dong, Yu Yong-An, Xu Shang-Gui, Zhao Hai, Chen Xin, Yan Jian-Jun
Shanghai Key Laboratory of Crime Scene Evidence, Institute of Forensic Science, Shanghai Public Security Bureau, Shanghai 200083, China.
Fa Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2011 Oct;27(5):324-6, 333.
To explore potential application of diatom test of lung tissue in investigation of cause of death in victim found in the water.
Four hundred and seven cases were collected and analyzed for cause of death and the nature of case. Diatom test was performed in tissues and the amount was quantified. Forty-five rabbits died in the water (antemortem, postmortem and different seasons drowning) were randomly divided into 9 groups and the diatom content in lung tissue were tested with the method of nitric acid.
In 407 drowning cases, 372 cases showed a positive result of diatom test. In positive cases, the amount of accidents or suicide were 35 and homicide were 21. Thirty-five cases showed negative result of diatom test and majority were homicide in which bodies were thrown into the water after killing. Some drowning cases were in special circumstances. Animal experiments confirmed that a large amount of diatoms in lung tissue were detected in drowning victim and showed the same type in water. The amount of diatom in lung tissue was usually lower in the summer and winter comparing with spring and autumn.
The diatom test could be considered as an auxiliary evidence in determination of cause of death in body found in the water. The test results were related with manner of death. The nature of case should be synthetically determined based on autopsy, criminal scene and details of the cases, etc.
探讨肺组织硅藻检验在水中尸体死因调查中的潜在应用。
收集407例案件,分析死因及案件性质。对组织进行硅藻检验并定量。将45只死于水中(生前、死后及不同季节溺水)的家兔随机分为9组,用硝酸法检测肺组织中的硅藻含量。
407例溺水案件中,372例硅藻检验呈阳性。阳性案例中,意外或自杀35例, homicide 21例。35例硅藻检验呈阴性,多数为 homicide ,即杀人后抛尸入水。部分溺水案例情况特殊。动物实验证实,溺水死者肺组织中可检测到大量硅藻,且与水中硅藻种类相同。与春秋季相比,夏季和冬季肺组织中的硅藻含量通常较低。
硅藻检验可作为水中尸体死因判定的辅助证据。检验结果与死亡方式有关。应综合尸体解剖、犯罪现场及案件细节等确定案件性质。