Institute of Environmental Assessment and Water Research (IDAEA-CSIC), Jordi Girona, 18, 08034 Barcelona, Spain.
Aquat Toxicol. 2012 Apr;110-111:114-22. doi: 10.1016/j.aquatox.2011.12.016. Epub 2011 Dec 31.
Thyroid disruption during early development is a current matter of concern due to its significant human health implications. We present here a transcriptome analysis of thyroid hormone-regulated genes in zebrafish during the eleutheroembryonic stage (days 2-5 post fertilization) to detect potential markers of thyroid disruption. Exposure to 3,5,3'-triiodo-l-thyroxine (T3, 50 nM) induced changes in a minor portion (less than 2%) of the zebrafish transcriptome, with a significant fraction of genes involved in the haematopoietic system, eye formation, and ossification/skeletal system, including the thyroid receptor thra gene. Some of the transcriptomic changes were reflected macroscopically, as an allometric decrease of eye size and an increase on thra hybridization signal in the skeletal tissue. Using this information, changes on transcription of three genes (adult alpha globin gene si:ch211-5 k11.6, embryonic globin gene hbae3, and long wavelength cone opsin gene opn1/w1) were analyzed to monitor the effect of the suspected thyroid disrupter bisphenol A (BPA) on the thyroid system during this period of development of zebrafish. BPA acted as a weak T3 agonist when tested alone, but it strongly enhanced the effect of subsaturating concentrations of T3. In thyroxine immunofluorescence quantitative disruption tests (TIQDT), BPA did not prevent the ability of thyroid follicles to synthesize thyroxine, a landmark for direct goitrogens. Our results suggest that BPA potentiates the effect of endogenous T3 in early development and demonstrate the requirement for the use of in vivo, multi-endpoint methods to evaluate thyroid disruption hazards on early developmental processes in vertebrates.
甲状腺在早期发育过程中的紊乱是当前关注的问题,因为它对人类健康有重大影响。我们在这里展示了在斑马鱼的原肠胚期(受精后第 2-5 天)对甲状腺激素调节基因的转录组分析,以检测潜在的甲状腺干扰标志物。暴露于 3,5,3'-三碘-l-甲状腺素(T3,50 nM)导致斑马鱼转录组中一小部分(小于 2%)发生变化,其中相当一部分基因参与造血系统、眼睛形成和骨化/骨骼系统,包括甲状腺受体 thra 基因。一些转录组变化在宏观上得到反映,表现为眼睛大小的比例减小和骨骼组织中 thra 杂交信号的增加。利用这些信息,分析了三个基因(成人α珠蛋白基因 si:ch211-5 k11.6、胚胎珠蛋白基因 hbae3 和长波锥状光感受蛋白基因 opn1/w1)的转录变化,以监测疑似甲状腺干扰物双酚 A(BPA)在这一时期对甲状腺系统的影响。单独测试时,BPA 作为一种弱 T3 激动剂起作用,但它强烈增强了亚饱和浓度 T3 的作用。在甲状腺素免疫荧光定量破坏测试(TIQDT)中,BPA 并没有阻止甲状腺滤泡合成甲状腺素的能力,这是直接致甲状腺肿剂的一个标志。我们的结果表明,BPA 增强了内源性 T3 在早期发育中的作用,并证明需要使用体内、多终点方法来评估甲状腺对脊椎动物早期发育过程的干扰危害。