Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2012 Aug 1;83(5):1528-33. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2011.10.052. Epub 2012 Jan 26.
We have observed a higher rate of Lhermitte sign (LS) after chemo-intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) of head-and-neck cancer than the published rates after conventional radiotherapy. We hypothesized that the inhomogeneous spinal cord dose distributions produced by IMRT caused a "bath-and-shower" effect, characterized by low doses in the vicinity of high doses, reducing spinal cord tolerance.
Seventy-three patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx participated in a prospective study of IMRT concurrent with weekly carboplatin and paclitaxel. Of these, 15 (21%) reported LS during at least 2 consecutive follow-up visits. Mean dose, maximum dose, and partial volume and absolute volume (in milliliters) of spinal cord receiving specified doses (≥10 Gy, ≥20 Gy, ≥30 Gy, and ≥40 Gy), as well as the pattern of dose distributions at the "anatomic" spinal cord (from the base of the skull to the aortic arch) and "plan-related" spinal cord (from the top through the bottom of the planning target volumes), were compared between LS patients and 34 non-LS patients.
LS patients had significantly higher spinal cord mean doses, V(30), V(40), and absolute volumes receiving 30 Gy or more and 40 Gy or more compared with the non-LS patients (p < 0.05). The strongest predictors of LS were higher V(40) and higher cord volumes receiving 40 Gy or more (p ≤ 0.007). There was no evidence of larger spinal cord volumes receiving low doses in the vicinity of higher doses (bath-and-shower effect) in LS compared with non-LS patients.
Greater mean dose, V(30), V(40), and cord volumes receiving 30 Gy or more and 40 Gy or more characterized LS compared with non-LS patients. Bath-and-shower effects could not be validated in this study as a potential contributor to LS. The higher-than-expected rates of LS may be because of the specific concurrent chemotherapy agents or more accurate identification of LS in the setting of a prospective study.
我们观察到头颈癌调强放疗(IMRT)后 Lhermitte 征(LS)的发生率高于传统放疗后的报道率。我们假设,IMRT 产生的脊髓剂量分布不均匀导致了“浴盆和淋浴”效应,即高剂量附近的低剂量,从而降低了脊髓的耐受性。
73 例口咽鳞癌患者参与了一项前瞻性研究,接受 IMRT 联合每周卡铂和紫杉醇治疗。其中 15 例(21%)在至少 2 次连续随访中报告有 LS。比较 LS 患者和 34 例非 LS 患者的脊髓平均剂量、最大剂量以及部分体积和绝对体积(毫升),分别为接受指定剂量(≥10Gy、≥20Gy、≥30Gy 和≥40Gy)的脊髓、“解剖学”脊髓(从颅底到主动脉弓)和“计划相关”脊髓(从计划靶区顶部到底部)的剂量分布模式。
LS 患者脊髓平均剂量、V30、V40 以及 30Gy 或 40Gy 以上的绝对体积均显著高于非 LS 患者(p<0.05)。LS 的最强预测因子是更高的 V40 和更高的脊髓 40Gy 或更高剂量的体积(p≤0.007)。与非 LS 患者相比,LS 患者并未发现高剂量附近接受低剂量的脊髓体积更大(浴盆和淋浴效应)。
与非 LS 患者相比,LS 患者的脊髓平均剂量、V30、V40 以及 30Gy 或 40Gy 以上的体积更大。LS 患者的脊髓体积更大,V30、V40 以及 30Gy 或 40Gy 以上的体积更大。在这项研究中,未能验证浴盆和淋浴效应是否是 LS 的潜在原因。LS 发生率高于预期,可能是由于特定的同期化疗药物,或在前瞻性研究中更准确地识别 LS。