Kenwright Kathleen, Liddell Patty W, Bloom Leonard, Zucker-Levin Audrey, Nolen Ann H, Faulkner Lawrence W, Batorski Rosemary E
University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Memphis, TN 38163, USA.
Clin Lab Sci. 2011 Fall;24(4):221-6.
The objective was twofold. The focus of the study was primarily to determine if the stress of a particularly difficult exam could cause students to lose the normal diurnal variation seen in human cortisol levels and secondarily, to validate the use of a competitive enzyme immunoassay for salivary cortisol.
Physical therapy students enrolled in Research Design were asked to participate in the study by collecting baseline evening and morning salivary cortisols during what was regarded as a relatively stress free time in the Fall of 2009. The following spring, the same students were asked for samples the evening before and morning of their first Kinesiology test, traditionally a stressful time. Method validation was accomplished using instrumentation owned by the Medical Laboratory Science (MLS) Program and analysis was performed by MLS faculty and a second year MLS student.
Participants were enrolled in the College of Health Sciences at the University of Tennessee in Memphis. Sample collection and testing was performed in the student laboratory of the Medical Laboratory Science Program.
Physical therapy students in their first year of a three-year entry level doctorate program, DPT.
This group of students did not lose their diurnal variation of cortisol. However, an unexpected finding was noted: the students' salivary cortisol specimen collected in the morning of the fall semester was significantly higher than the salivary cortisol specimen collected the morning of the test in the spring semester (p = .019). Method validation was successful demonstrating a strong correlation ( r = 0.915) when compared to the reference laboratory.
Cortisol diurnal variation was not lost in the study participants, but further studies should be performed due to the low percentage of students completing the study and the lack of demographic diversity. Even though the method validation in the student laboratory setting demonstrates that it is indeed possible to obtain the same excellent correlation as is seen in a clinical setting, the student laboratory is not CLIA certified, so assays can be performed for research use only.
本研究有两个目的。主要目的是确定一场特别难的考试带来的压力是否会导致学生失去人类皮质醇水平正常的昼夜变化规律,其次是验证竞争性酶免疫测定法用于检测唾液皮质醇的有效性。
参加研究设计课程的物理治疗专业学生被要求参与本研究,在2009年秋季这段相对无压力的时间里收集晚间和晨间的唾液皮质醇基线数据。次年春天,同样这些学生被要求在他们第一次运动机能学考试的前一晚和当天早上提供样本,而这门考试通常是压力较大的时候。方法验证使用医学检验科学(MLS)项目所拥有的仪器完成,分析由MLS教员和一名MLS专业二年级学生进行。
参与者就读于田纳西大学孟菲斯分校健康科学学院。样本采集和检测在医学检验科学项目的学生实验室进行。
参加为期三年的入门级博士学位课程(DPT)第一年的物理治疗专业学生。
这群学生并未失去皮质醇的昼夜变化规律。然而,有一个意外发现:秋季学期早晨采集的学生唾液皮质醇样本显著高于春季学期考试当天早晨采集的唾液皮质醇样本(p = 0.019)。与参考实验室相比,方法验证成功,显示出很强的相关性(r = 0.915)。
研究参与者并未失去皮质醇的昼夜变化规律,但由于完成研究的学生比例较低且缺乏人口统计学多样性,应开展进一步研究。尽管在学生实验室环境下的方法验证表明确实有可能获得与临床环境中相同的良好相关性,但学生实验室未获得临床实验室改进修正案(CLIA)认证,因此检测仅可用于研究目的。