Rafferty Amy, Martin Jane, Strachan David, Raine Chris
Yorkshire Cochlear Implant Service, Bradford Royal Infirmary, Bradford BD9 6RJ, UK.
Cochlear Implants Int. 2013 Mar;14(2):61-6. doi: 10.1179/1754762810Y.0000000009. Epub 2011 Jun 29.
Prospective review of the assessment and outcomes of children with complex needs receiving cochlear implants (CIs) at the Yorkshire Cochlear Implant Service (YCIS).
Nineteen children with complex needs were assessed pre-implant and 12 months post-implant switch-on using appropriate developmental-related audiology, categories of auditory performance (CAP), meaningful auditory information scale (MAIS), listening progress score (LiP), and meaningful use of speech scale (MUSS). Outcomes were compared with 230 children at the YCIS without complex needs.
Average CAP scores improved from 0.4 to 3.0, compared with 4.2 in the control group. MAIS scores as completed by parent and teacher improved to 62 and 57%, respectively, compared with the control group who achieved 82 and 70% at 12 months. LiP scores improved from 11 to 65% compared with the control which increased from 22 to 81%. MUSS scores as assessed by parent and teacher improved to 35 and 31%, respectively, at 12 months compared with 52 and 51% in the control group.
CIs in children have been shown to be cost effective and provide benefits in auditory and speech perception; however, there are few reports specifically relating to outcomes in children with complex needs. Improvement was seen across all outcome measures although less than in children without additional needs. Consideration should be given to the use of quality-of-life measurements as the development of oral communication may not be a realistic goal or accurately reflect benefits gained by the use of CIs in this patient group.
对约克郡人工耳蜗服务中心(YCIS)接受人工耳蜗植入(CI)的有复杂需求儿童的评估及结果进行前瞻性回顾。
对19名有复杂需求的儿童在植入前以及开机后12个月进行评估,使用与发育相关的适当听力学评估方法、听觉表现类别(CAP)、有意义听觉信息量表(MAIS)、听力进步评分(LiP)和言语有意义使用量表(MUSS)。将结果与YCIS的230名无复杂需求儿童进行比较。
平均CAP评分从0.4提高到3.0,而对照组为4.2。家长和教师完成的MAIS评分分别提高到62%和57%,相比之下,对照组在12个月时达到82%和70%。LiP评分从11%提高到65%,而对照组从22%提高到81%。家长和教师评估的MUSS评分在12个月时分别提高到35%和31%,而对照组为52%和51%。
已证明儿童人工耳蜗具有成本效益,并在听觉和言语感知方面带来益处;然而,关于有复杂需求儿童的结果的具体报告很少。尽管所有结果指标都有改善,但改善程度低于无额外需求的儿童。应考虑使用生活质量测量方法,因为发展口语交流可能不是一个现实目标,也不能准确反映该患者群体使用人工耳蜗所获得的益处。