Derry Christopher J, Derry Sheena, Moore R Andrew
Pain Research and Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences (Nuffield Division of Anaesthetics), University of Oxford, Oxford,UK.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 Feb 15;2012(2):CD009665. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009665.
Migraine is a highly disabling condition for the individual and also has wide-reaching implications for society, healthcare services, and the economy. Sumatriptan is an abortive medication for migraine attacks, belonging to the triptan family. Subcutaneous administration may be preferable to oral for individuals experiencing nausea and/or vomiting
To determine the efficacy and tolerability of subcutaneous sumatriptan compared to placebo and other active interventions in the treatment of acute migraine attacks in adults.
We searched Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE, EMBASE, online databases, and reference lists for studies through 13 October 2011.
We included randomised, double-blind, placebo- and/or active-controlled studies using subcutaneous sumatriptan to treat a migraine headache episode, with at least 10 participants per treatment arm.
Two review authors independently assessed trial quality and extracted data. We used numbers of participants achieving each outcome to calculate relative risk (or 'risk ratio') and numbers needed to treat to benefit (NNT) or harm (NNH) compared to placebo or a different active treatment.
Thirty-five studies (9365 participants) compared subcutaneous sumatriptan with placebo or an active comparator. Most of the data were for the 6 mg dose. Sumatriptan surpassed placebo for all efficacy outcomes. For sumatriptan 6 mg versus placebo the NNTs were 2.9, 2.3, 2.2, and 2.1 for pain-free at one and two hours, and headache relief at one and two hours, respectively, and 6.1 for sustained pain-free at 24 hours. Results for the 4 mg and 8 mg doses were similar to the 6 mg dose, with 6 mg significantly better than 4 mg only for pain-free at one hour, and 8 mg significantly better than 6 mg only for headache relief at one hour. There was no evidence of increased migraine relief if a second dose of sumatriptan 6 mg was given after an inadequate response to the first.Relief of headache-associated symptoms, including nausea, photophobia, and phonophobia, was greater with sumatriptan than with placebo, and use of rescue medication was lower with sumatriptan than placebo. For the most part, adverse events were transient and mild and were more common with sumatriptan than placebo.Sumatriptan was compared directly with a number of active treatments, including other triptans, acetylsalicylic acid plus metoclopramide, and dihydroergotamine, but there were insufficient data for any pooled analyses.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Subcutaneous sumatriptan is effective as an abortive treatment for acute migraine attacks, quickly relieving pain, nausea, photophobia, phonophobia, and functional disability, but is associated with increased adverse events.
偏头痛对个人而言是一种致残性很强的疾病,对社会、医疗服务及经济也有广泛影响。舒马曲坦是一种用于偏头痛发作的终止性药物,属于曲坦类药物。对于有恶心和/或呕吐症状的患者,皮下注射给药可能优于口服给药。
确定皮下注射舒马曲坦与安慰剂及其他活性干预措施相比,在治疗成人急性偏头痛发作时的疗效和耐受性。
我们检索了Cochrane对照试验中央登记库(CENTRAL)、MEDLINE、EMBASE、在线数据库,并查阅了截至2011年10月13日的研究参考文献列表。
我们纳入了使用皮下注射舒马曲坦治疗偏头痛发作的随机、双盲、安慰剂和/或活性对照研究,每个治疗组至少有10名参与者。
两名综述作者独立评估试验质量并提取数据。我们使用达到各结局的参与者数量来计算相对风险(或“风险比”),以及与安慰剂或不同活性治疗相比的获益所需治疗人数(NNT)或伤害所需治疗人数(NNH)。
35项研究(9365名参与者)将皮下注射舒马曲坦与安慰剂或活性对照进行了比较。大部分数据针对的是6毫克剂量。在所有疗效结局方面,舒马曲坦均优于安慰剂。对于舒马曲坦6毫克与安慰剂相比,1小时和2小时无痛、1小时和2小时头痛缓解以及24小时持续无痛的NNT分别为2.9、2.3、2.2和2.1,24小时持续无痛的NNT为6.1。4毫克和8毫克剂量的结果与6毫克剂量相似,仅在1小时无痛方面6毫克显著优于4毫克,仅在1小时头痛缓解方面8毫克显著优于6毫克。没有证据表明在首次给药反应不足后给予第二剂舒马曲坦6毫克会增加偏头痛缓解效果。与安慰剂相比,舒马曲坦对包括恶心、畏光和畏声在内的与头痛相关症状的缓解作用更强,且舒马曲坦使用急救药物的情况少于安慰剂。在大多数情况下,不良事件是短暂且轻微的,舒马曲坦组比安慰剂组更常见。舒马曲坦与多种活性治疗进行了直接比较,包括其他曲坦类药物、乙酰水杨酸加甲氧氯普胺和双氢麦角胺,但没有足够的数据进行任何汇总分析。
皮下注射舒马曲坦作为急性偏头痛发作的终止性治疗有效,能迅速缓解疼痛、恶心、畏光、畏声和功能障碍,但会增加不良事件的发生。