National Cancer Institute Regina Elena, Rome, Italy.
J Palliat Med. 2012 Feb;15(2):225-7. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2011.0306.
Despite aggressive multimodality treatment the prognosis of patients with primary brain tumors (BT) remains poor. At present, there are no data about the role of palliative home-care services and their impact on quality of care. We report the results of a pilot project of palliative home care for BT patients started in 2000 in the National Cancer Institute Regina Elena of Rome. We report also the result of a cost/effectiveness analysis utilizing administrative data on re-hospitalization rate in the last two months of life.
Since October 2000 until December 2009, 572 patients have been followed by our home care staff. Among 394 patients who died, 276 (70%) were followed at home until death. A cost/effectiveness analysis was carried out evaluating the rehospitalization rate in the last 2 months of life in a subgroup of patients (group 1 assisted at home, 72 patients; group 2 not assisted at home, 71). The number of hospital readmission in the last 2 months of life, and length and cost of hospitalization were retrospectively analyzed from hospital discharge records.
Hospitalization rate of group 1 (16.7%) was lower than group 2 (38%) (95% CI: 0.18-0.65, p = 0.001). Costs of hospitalization also differed substantially: 517 Euros (95% CI: 512-522) in group 1 vs 24, 076 Euros (95%: 24,040-24,112 Euros) in group 2.
Home-care may represent an alternative to in-hospital care for the management of brain tumor patients and may improve the end-of-life quality of care.
尽管采用了积极的多模式治疗,原发性脑肿瘤(BT)患者的预后仍然很差。目前,尚无关于姑息性家庭护理服务的作用及其对护理质量的影响的数据。我们报告了 2000 年在罗马 Regina Elena 国家癌症研究所开始的 BT 患者姑息性家庭护理试点项目的结果。我们还报告了利用关于生命最后两个月再住院率的行政数据进行的成本效益分析的结果。
自 2000 年 10 月至 2009 年 12 月,我们的家庭护理人员共随访了 572 例患者。在 394 例死亡的患者中,有 276 例(70%)在家中接受临终关怀直至死亡。在一组患者(在家中接受姑息治疗的患者 1 组,72 例;未在家中接受姑息治疗的患者 2 组,71 例)中进行了成本效益分析,评估了生命最后两个月的再住院率。从出院记录中回顾性分析了生命最后 2 个月的住院次数、住院时间和住院费用。
第 1 组(16.7%)的住院率低于第 2 组(38%)(95%CI:0.18-0.65,p = 0.001)。住院费用也有显著差异:第 1 组为 517 欧元(95%CI:512-522 欧元),第 2 组为 24076 欧元(95%:24040-24012 欧元)。
家庭护理可能是脑肿瘤患者管理的一种替代住院治疗的方法,并可改善临终关怀质量。