Differential efficacy of lipophilic and cytosolic antioxidants on generation of reactive oxygen species by amyloid-ß.

Exposure of neurons to amyloid-beta (Abeta) is accompanied by a cascade of oxidative damage that initiates with lipid peroxidation followed by subsequent generation of cytosolic free radicals and reactive oxygen species (ROS). The antioxidant vitamin E has been utilized to counteract Abeta-induced oxidative stress. We considered herein whether or not the lipid-solubility of vitamin E limits its neuroprotection to membrane-related oxidative damage, and renders it relatively ineffective where prior lipid peroxidation has already generated cytosolic free radicals and ROS. To test this possibility, we treated differentiated SH-SY-5Y human neuroblastoma with vitamin E or a cell-permeant antioxidant, N-acetyl cysteine (NAC), simultaneously with or 15 min after the application of Abeta. Both vitamin E and NAC prevented Abeta-induced ROS generation when applied simultaneously with Abeta, but only NAC prevented Abeta-induced ROS generation when added to cultures that had previously been exposed to Abeta. These results support the hypothesis that vitamin E can quench Abeta-induced lipid peroxidation, but cannot effectively quench ROS generated by prior lipid peroxidation. These findings in cell culture may provide limited insight into why vitamin E is not fully effective against neurodegeneration in AD in clinical settings, since some neuronal populations are likely to already have been compromised by prior Abeta exposure before vitamin E treatment was initiated.