Ghent University, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, Department of Experimental Psychology and Ghent Institute for Functional and Metabolic Imaging, Henri Dunantlaan 2, 9000 Gent, Belgium.
Neuroimage. 2012 May 15;61(1):289-94. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.02.065. Epub 2012 Mar 3.
Processing of subjective pleasantness is essential in daily life decision making, particularly in the context of cognitive and environmental factors. Pleasure is mediated by a neural network and this network has been suggested to be the biological basis of pleasure including a whole range of different modalities and domains of pleasantness. This quantitative meta-analysis of brain imaging data focuses on studies 1) based on correlations between self-reported judgements of pleasantness and brain regions and investigates whether 2) immediate (during scanning) versus subsequent judgements (after scanning) differ in brain activity. We investigated concurrence across 40 studies reporting brain regions correlated with self-reported judgements of subjective pleasantness (attractiveness, liking or beauty) by means of activation likelihood estimation (ALE). Positive correlates of subjective pleasantness were found in mOFC, ventromedial prefrontal cortex, left ventral striatum, pregenual cortex, right cerebellum, left thalamus and the mid cingulate cortex. Negative correlates were found in left precentral gyrus, right cerebellum and right inferior frontal gyrus. A comparison of studies with subjective pleasantness judgement during or after scanning revealed no significant differences in brain activation. We conclude that subjective pleasantness judgements are directly related to brain regions that have been described as part of the reward circuitry (mOFC, ventral striatum). The results suggest that the evaluation of likability or pleasure is an automatic process and that it is neither elicited nor enhanced by instructions to report the outcome of these judgements.
主观愉悦的处理在日常生活决策中至关重要,特别是在认知和环境因素的背景下。愉悦是由神经网络介导的,该网络被认为是愉悦的生物学基础,包括一系列不同的模式和愉悦领域。这项脑成像数据的定量荟萃分析主要关注基于自我报告的愉悦判断与大脑区域之间的相关性的研究 1),并研究 2)即时(扫描期间)与后续(扫描后)判断的大脑活动是否不同。我们通过激活似然估计(ALE)调查了 40 项报告与自我报告的主观愉悦判断相关的大脑区域的研究的一致性(吸引力、喜欢或美感)。主观愉悦的正相关在 mOFC、腹内侧前额叶皮层、左腹侧纹状体、前扣带回、右小脑、左丘脑和中扣带皮层中发现。负相关在左中央前回、右小脑和右额下回发现。对在扫描期间或之后进行主观愉悦判断的研究进行比较,发现大脑激活没有显著差异。我们的结论是,主观愉悦判断与已被描述为奖励回路一部分的大脑区域直接相关(mOFC、腹侧纹状体)。结果表明,对喜欢或愉悦的评价是一个自动过程,指令报告这些判断的结果既不会引起也不会增强这种评价。