Department of Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy.
Brain Topogr. 2012 Oct;25(4):345-61. doi: 10.1007/s10548-012-0225-2. Epub 2012 Apr 5.
The aim of this work is to improve fMRI Granger Causality Analysis (GCA) by proposing and comparing two strategies for defining the topology of the networks among which cerebral connectivity is measured and to apply fMRI GCA for studying epileptic seizure propagation. The first proposed method is based on information derived from anatomical atlas only; the other one is based on functional information and employs an algorithm of hierarchical clustering applied to fMRI data directly. Both methods were applied to signals recorded during seizures on a group of epileptic subjects and two connectivity matrices were obtained for each patient. The performances of the different parcellation strategies were evaluated in terms of their capability to recover information about the source and the sink of the network (i.e., the starting and the ending point of the seizure propagation). The first method allows to clearly identify the seizure onset in all patients, whereas the network sources are not so immediately recognizable when the second method was used. Nevertheless, results obtained using functional clustering do not contradict those obtained with the anatomical atlas and are able to individuate the main pattern of propagation. In conclusion, the way nodes are defined can influence the easiness of identification of the epileptogenic focus but does not produce contradictory results showing the effectiveness of proposed approach to formulate hypothesis about seizure propagation at least in the early phase of investigation.
这项工作的目的是通过提出和比较两种策略来改进功能磁共振成像 Granger 因果关系分析(GCA),以定义所测量的大脑连接网络的拓扑结构,并应用 fMRI GCA 来研究癫痫发作的传播。第一种方法是基于解剖图谱的信息;另一种方法基于功能信息,并直接应用层次聚类算法对 fMRI 数据进行分析。这两种方法都应用于一组癫痫患者发作期间记录的信号,并为每个患者获得了两个连接矩阵。通过评估不同分区策略在恢复网络源和汇(即癫痫传播的起始点和结束点)信息的能力方面,评估了不同分区策略的性能。第一种方法可以清楚地识别所有患者的癫痫发作起始,而当使用第二种方法时,网络源则不太容易识别。然而,使用功能聚类获得的结果与使用解剖图谱获得的结果并不矛盾,并且能够确定主要的传播模式。总之,节点的定义方式可能会影响癫痫灶的识别难易程度,但不会产生矛盾的结果,这表明了所提出的方法在至少在研究的早期阶段提出关于癫痫传播的假设的有效性。