Paolino E, Granieri E, Tola M R, Govoni V, Casetta I, Monetti V C, Carreras M
Instituto di Clinica Neurologica, dell'Università di Ferrara.
Riv Neurol. 1990 Mar-Apr;60(2):73-81.
Spatial-temporal dissemination of neurological signs is an essential criterion for establishing a definite diagnosis of Multiple Sclerosis (MS). Unfortunately, we often observe patients who present a history consistent with MS but without objectivity indicating the presence of at least two or more distinct lesions of Central Nervous System (CNS). In recent years, many Authors have emphasized the use of Multimodal Evoked Responses (MER), Cerebrospinal Fluid (CSF) analysis for the research of Oligoclonal Bands (OB), and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) as highly sensitive techniques for demonstrating the spreading of the lesions. This study, carried out to evaluate whether the combined use of these three methods would increase the diagnostic MS sensitivity, comprises 62 patients classified in Definite (n = 24). Probable (n = 18) and Possible (n = 20) MS according to the clinical criteria of McAlpine. All our cases fulfilled a complete ER evaluation (VER, SER, BAER), a paired CSF and serum Isoelectric focusing (IEF) and a cerebral MRI. Moreover, IgG Index was also estimated. CSF IEF was the most sensitive test in Definite (91.7%) and Possible (80.0%) MS, nearly followed by MRI (87.5% and 45.0% respectively). VER (87.5% and 60.0%) and SER (87.5% and 65.0%). On the contrary, MRI showed the higher sensitivity in Probable MS (94.4%). The course of the disease influenced only SER and VER in all diagnostic group, while the duration correlated positively with BAER and VER. Only VER and BAER, finally, supplied additional information about the not revealed clinically or by MRI CNS disorders. Thus, our data further emphasize the value of combining these laboratory tests for establishing an early and more accurate diagnosis of MS.
神经体征的时空分布是明确诊断多发性硬化症(MS)的重要标准。不幸的是,我们经常观察到一些患者,他们的病史与MS相符,但缺乏客观证据表明存在至少两个或更多不同的中枢神经系统(CNS)病变。近年来,许多作者强调使用多模态诱发电位(MER)、脑脊液(CSF)分析以检测寡克隆带(OB),以及磁共振成像(MRI)作为显示病变扩散的高灵敏度技术。本研究旨在评估这三种方法联合使用是否会提高MS诊断的敏感性,纳入了62例根据McAlpine临床标准分类为确诊(n = 24)、可能(n = 18)和疑似(n = 20)MS的患者。我们所有的病例均完成了完整的诱发电位评估(视觉诱发电位、体感诱发电位、脑干听觉诱发电位)、配对的脑脊液和血清等电聚焦(IEF)以及脑部MRI检查。此外,还估算了IgG指数。脑脊液IEF在确诊MS(91.7%)和疑似MS(80.0%)中是最敏感的检测方法,其次是MRI(分别为87.5%和45.0%)。视觉诱发电位(87.5%和60.0%)和体感诱发电位(87.5%和65.0%)。相反,MRI在可能MS中显示出更高的敏感性(94.4%)。疾病进程仅影响所有诊断组中的体感诱发电位和视觉诱发电位,而病程与脑干听觉诱发电位和视觉诱发电位呈正相关。最后,只有视觉诱发电位和脑干听觉诱发电位提供了有关未在临床或MRI中显示的中枢神经系统疾病的额外信息。因此,我们的数据进一步强调了联合这些实验室检查对于早期、更准确地诊断MS的价值。