Das Sibes Kumar, Das Anirban, Saha Samirendra Kumar, Biswas Saurabh
North Bengal Medical College and Hospital, Sushrutanagar 734012.
J Indian Med Assoc. 2011 Oct;109(10):730-2, 741.
Diagnostic yield of broncho-alveolar lavage (BAL) fluid and postbronchoscopic sputum (PBS) cytology is very high in endoscopically visible bronchogenic carcinoma, but they are also helpful in diagnosis of those lung cancers which are not visible bronchoscopically. Objective of this prospective study is to analyse the diagnostic yield of BAL fluid and PBS cytology in endoscopically non-visible lung cancer. Thirty patients with chest radiographic abnormality suspicious of lung cancer without endobronchial abnormality underwent BAL fluid and PBS cytology examination in the department of respiratory medicine of Calcutta National Medical College and Hospital over 1 year and 3 months. The final diagnosis was bronchogenic carcinoma in 21, tuberculoma/tuberculosis in 5, bacterial pneumonia in 3 and encysted empyema in 1. Among the 21 patients with bronchogenic carcinoma, BAL was positive for malignant cell in 13 patients (62%). The diagnostic yield of the BAL was influenced by size, location, radiographic pattern and cell type of the tumour. PBS cytology was positive in 3 patients (14%) only, all of which were positive with BAL fluid also. BAL fluid cytology proved to be a valuable diagnostic tool in diagnosis of endoscopically non-visible lung cancer. Size, location, radiographic pattern and cytological type of the lesions were important determinants of the diagnostic yield. PBS cytology provided no additional benefit.
支气管肺泡灌洗(BAL)液和支气管镜检查后痰液(PBS)细胞学检查对于内镜可见的支气管源性癌诊断阳性率很高,但它们对于那些支气管镜下不可见的肺癌诊断也有帮助。这项前瞻性研究的目的是分析BAL液和PBS细胞学检查在支气管镜下不可见肺癌中的诊断阳性率。在加尔各答国立医学院和医院呼吸内科,1年零3个月期间,30例胸部X线片异常怀疑肺癌但无支气管内异常的患者接受了BAL液和PBS细胞学检查。最终诊断为支气管源性癌21例,结核瘤/结核病5例,细菌性肺炎3例,包裹性脓胸1例。在21例支气管源性癌患者中,13例(62%)BAL液中恶性细胞呈阳性。BAL的诊断阳性率受肿瘤大小、位置、影像学表现和细胞类型的影响。PBS细胞学检查仅3例(14%)呈阳性,且这3例BAL液检查也呈阳性。BAL液细胞学检查被证明是诊断支气管镜下不可见肺癌的一种有价值的诊断工具。病变的大小、位置、影像学表现和细胞学类型是诊断阳性率的重要决定因素。PBS细胞学检查未提供额外帮助。