Overgaard M, Christensen J J, Johansen H, Nybo-Rasmussen A, Rose C, van der Kooy P, Panduro J, Laursen F, Kjaer M, Sørensen N E
Department of Oncology, Radiumstationen, Aarhus, Denmark.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1990 Nov;19(5):1121-4. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(90)90214-5.
The role of postmastectomy irradiation together with systemic treatment was evaluated in high-risk patients included in the Danish Breast Cancer Cooperative Group (DBCG) protocol 82. As of June 1989, a total of 1473 pre- and menopausal patients were randomized to postmastectomy irradiation + CMF versus CMF alone (protocol 82-b). A total of 1202 postmenopausal patients were randomized to postmastectomy irradiation + Tamoxifen versus Tamoxifen alone (protocol 82-c). At 5 years the actuarial loco-regional recurrence rate was significantly lower in the irradiated patients (82-b: 9% vs 28%, 82-c: 6% vs 36%). Further, disease-free survival was significantly improved in both pre- and postmenopausal irradiated patients compared with those who had only systemic treatment (82-b: 54% vs 47%, 82-c: 52% vs 38%). At present, overall survival is significantly different in 82-b patients (68% vs 63%) but not in post-menopausal 82-c patients (62% vs 61%). Thus, adjuvant systemic treatment alone (chemotherapy or tamoxifen) did not prevent loco-regional recurrences in high-risk patients after mastectomy and axillary lymph node sampling. However, a longer observation time is necessary to evaluate the consequence of primary optimal loco-regional tumor control in high-risk breast cancer patients with respect to overall survival.
在丹麦乳腺癌合作组(DBCG)82号方案纳入的高危患者中,评估了乳房切除术后放疗联合全身治疗的作用。截至1989年6月,共有1473例绝经前和绝经患者被随机分为乳房切除术后放疗+CMF组与单纯CMF组(82 - b方案)。共有1202例绝经后患者被随机分为乳房切除术后放疗+他莫昔芬组与单纯他莫昔芬组(82 - c方案)。5年时,接受放疗患者的精算局部区域复发率显著更低(82 - b方案:9%对28%,82 - c方案:6%对36%)。此外,与仅接受全身治疗的患者相比,绝经前和绝经后接受放疗的患者无病生存率均显著提高(82 - b方案:54%对47%,82 - c方案:52%对38%)。目前,82 - b方案患者的总生存率有显著差异(68%对63%),但绝经后82 - c方案患者无显著差异(62%对61%)。因此,单纯辅助全身治疗(化疗或他莫昔芬)不能预防高危患者乳房切除术后及腋窝淋巴结取样后的局部区域复发。然而,对于高危乳腺癌患者总体生存而言,需要更长的观察时间来评估原发灶局部区域肿瘤最佳控制的后果。