Parente Hernández B, Sentieri Omarrementería A, Junceda Moreno J
Departamento de Oftalmología, Hospital de Cabueñes, Gijón, Asturias, España.
Arch Soc Esp Oftalmol. 2012 May;87(5):139-44. doi: 10.1016/j.oftal.2011.10.009. Epub 2012 Apr 3.
To describe current surgical techniques of dacryocystorhinostomy (DCR) and to compare their effectiveness by analysing the advantages and disadvantages between external, endonasal and transcanalicular surgery.
A total of 91 DCRs were analysed using a retrospective, cross-sectional and multicentre study in 75 patients who had symptoms of nasolacrimal duct obstruction. Of these, 28 were operated using external DCR, 31 endonasal technic, and 32 transcanalicular DCR with diode laser. Outcomes were evaluated subjectively using patient symptoms for the grade of epiphora and the results from the syringing before and after surgery.
External DCR was performed in 28 cases, with 19 cases asymptomatic (67.85%), and 20 patients had a patent tract (71.42%). Endonasal DCR was performed in 31 cases, of which 19 cases were asymptomatic (61.29%), and 21 showed patency of the nasolacrimal duct (67.74%). A transcanalicular technique was performed in 32 cases, with absence of epiphora in 24 patients (75%), and the syringing was successful in 24 of them (75%).
Any of these 3 surgery techniques would be an adequate treatment for lacrimal obstruction, due to the significant development of endonasal and transcanalicular techniques in recent decades. With improvement, we could use either endonasal or transcanalicular techniques with diode laser with the same lever of effectiveness as the classic external approach, with the advantages of minimally invasive surgery.
描述当前泪囊鼻腔吻合术(DCR)的手术技术,并通过分析外路、鼻内镜和经泪小管手术的优缺点来比较它们的有效性。
采用回顾性、横断面多中心研究,分析75例有鼻泪管阻塞症状患者的91例DCR手术。其中,28例行外路DCR手术,31例行鼻内镜技术手术,32例行经泪小管DCR联合二极管激光手术。采用患者症状主观评估溢泪程度,并比较手术前后泪道冲洗结果来评价手术效果。
28例行外路DCR手术,19例无症状(67.85%),20例泪道通畅(71.42%)。31例行鼻内镜DCR手术,19例无症状(61.29%),21例鼻泪管通畅(67.74%)。32例行经泪小管技术手术,24例无溢泪(75%),其中24例泪道冲洗成功(75%)。
由于近几十年来鼻内镜和经泪小管技术的显著发展,这三种手术技术中的任何一种都足以治疗泪道阻塞。随着技术的改进,我们可以使用鼻内镜或经泪小管联合二极管激光技术,其有效性与传统外路手术相当,且具有微创手术的优势。